Renormalized Magic Angles in Asymmetric Twisted Graphene Multilayers

Adam Eaton,Yantao Li,Herbert Fertig,Babak Seradjeh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.106.045117

2022-06-08

Abstract:Stacked graphene multilayers with a small relative twist angle between each of the layers have been found to host flat bands at a series of magic angles. We consider the effect that Dirac point asymmetry between the layers, and in particular different Fermi velocities in each layer, may have on this phenomenon. Such asymmetry may be introduced by unequal Fermi velocity renormalizations through Coulomb interactions with a dielectric substrate. It also arises in an approximate way in tetralayer systems, in which the outer twist angles are large enough that there is a dominant moire periodicity from the stacking of the inner two layers. We find in such models that the flat band phenomenon persists in spite of this asymmetry, and that the magic angles acquire a degree of tunability through either controlling the screening in the bilayer system or the twist angles of the outer layers in the tetralayer system. Notably, we find in our models that the quantitative values of the magic angles are increased.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore how the magic angles phenomenon is affected by the inter - layer Dirac point asymmetry in an asymmetrically twisted multilayer graphene system. Specifically, the researchers focus on the influence of the difference in Fermi velocities between different layers on the formation of flat bands, and whether these differences will lead to changes in the magic angle positions.

#### Main problems include:

1. **Robustness of the magic angles phenomenon**:
- The researchers hope to verify whether the magic angles phenomenon still exists in the case of inter - layer Dirac point asymmetry. By introducing different Fermi velocities, they explore the specific impact of this asymmetry on the magic angle.

2. **Adjustability of the magic angle**:
- This study also explores how to adjust the position of the magic angle by controlling the screening effect of the bilayer system or the twisting angle of the outer layers in the four - layer system. It is found that the quantitative value of the magic angle has increased, indicating that the magic angle has a certain degree of adjustability.

3. **Consistency between theoretical models and experimental results**:
- In order to understand these phenomena, the researchers propose an improved Bistritzer - MacDonald (BM) model and analyze it through perturbation theory and numerical simulation. The results show that the magic angles phenomenon still exists in the case of Dirac point asymmetry, and the position of the magic angle can be controlled by adjusting the Fermi velocity ratio.

#### Summary of mathematical formulas:

- **Magic angle condition**:
\[
\hbar k_\theta\sqrt{v_1v_2}/w = \sqrt{3}
\]
where \(v_1\) and \(v_2\) are the Fermi velocities of the two - layer coupled Dirac points, \(w\) is the inter - layer tunneling strength, \(k_\theta = 2k_D\sin(\theta/2)\) is the separation distance between the twisted Dirac points determined by the twisting angle \(\theta\), and \(k_D\) is the separation distance between the K and K' points in single - layer graphene.

- **Renormalized Fermi velocity**:
\[
v'_l = v_l-\frac{3\alpha^2_{\bar{l}}v_{\bar{l}}}{1 + 3(1 + u^2)\alpha^2_{\bar{l}}}
\]
where \(\alpha_l = w/(\hbar k_\theta v_l)\), and \(u\) is the tunneling amplitude ratio between the same sub - lattice and different sub - lattices.

- **Effective Fermi velocity**:
\[
v_{\text{eff},2}=\frac{\beta_1\beta_4v'_2 - 3z^2(\alpha'_3)^2v'_3}{z\beta_1\beta_4 + 3(1 + u^2)(\alpha'_3)^2}
\]
\[
v_{\text{eff},3}=\frac{\beta_1\beta_4v'_3 - 3z^2(\alpha'_2)^2v'_2}{z\beta_1\beta_4 + 3(1 + u^2)(\alpha'_2)^2}
\]
where \(\alpha'_2 = w/(\hbar k_{\theta,23}v'_2)\), \(\alpha'_3 = w/(\hbar k_{\theta,23}v'_3)\), and \(z\) is the ratio of the bare tunneling amplitude between layer 2 and layer 3 to the tunneling amplitude between bilayer 12 and 34.

Through these studies, the authors reveal the robustness and adjustability of the magic angles phenomenon in the case of Dirac point asymmetry, providing a theoretical basis for understanding and designing more complex twisted multilayer graphene systems.