Moiré optical phonons dancing with heavy electrons in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene

Hao Shi,Wangqian Miao,Xi Dai

2024-02-19

Abstract:Electron-phonon coupling in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene is an important but difficult topic. We propose a scheme to simplify and understand this problem. Weighted by the coupling strength with the low-energy heavy electrons ($f$ orbitals), several moiré optical phonons are singled out which strongly couple to the flat bands. These modes have localized envelopes in the moiré scale, while in the atomic scale they inherit the monolayer oscillations like the Kekulé pattern. They flip the flavor of $f$ orbitals, helping stabilize some symmetry-breaking orders. Such electron-phonon couplings are incorporated into an effective extended Holstein model, where both phonons and electrons are written as moiré scale basis. We hope this model will inspire some insights guiding further studies about the superconductivity and other correlated effects in this system.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to simplify and understand the electron - phonon coupling (EPC) problem in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG). Specifically, the authors propose a scheme to identify and construct moiré optical phonon modes that are strongly coupled to flat bands. These modes have localized envelopes on the moiré scale and inherit the vibration modes of monolayer graphene on the atomic scale, such as the Kekulé pattern. These phonon modes can flip the flavor of f - orbitals and contribute to stabilizing some symmetry - breaking orders. By incorporating these electron - phonon couplings into an extended Holstein model, the authors hope that this model can provide new insights into the research of superconductivity and other related effects.

### Main research contents

1. **Problem background**:
- Magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) has eight flat bands near the charge neutral point and exhibits fascinating transport and optical properties.
- In recent years, high - resolution STM experiments have revealed the Kekulé pattern on the atomic scale, indicating the existence of inter - valley coherent properties.
- Nano - Raman and µ - ARPES experiments further suggest that optical phonons may play an important role in MATBG.

2. **Theoretical challenges**:
- Rigorously and thoroughly treating moiré phonons is an extremely complex task because there are more than 30,000 moiré phonon branches in MATBG.
- Even if all phonons are exactly diagonalized, the subsequent EPC data processing is very complex and it is difficult to obtain a clear physical understanding.

3. **Simplified model**:
- The authors simplify the EPC model by constructing moiré optical phonon modes that are strongly coupled to flat bands.
- The basic idea is to start from the monolayer - folded phonon modes, which serve as a suitable basis set.
- By considering the coupling strength with f - orbitals, the authors manually construct several moiré phonon modes. These modes are mainly distributed in the AA - stacked region on the moiré scale and inherit the monolayer vibration modes on the atomic scale.

4. **Numerical implementation**:
- The authors use two methods to determine these moiré phonon modes: one is based on an approximate layer - decoupled continuous EPC model, and the other is a frozen - phonon method based on a more realistic tight - binding model.
- Through these methods, the authors identify 9 moiré phonon modes that are strongly coupled to flat bands and analyze their symmetry and spatial distribution.

5. **Impact assessment**:
- The authors study the impact of these moiré phonon modes on different symmetry - breaking states through the mean - field theory.
- The results show that the phonon - mediated attractive channels are favorable for the T - invariant inter - valley coherent (TIVC) state and the T - invariant semimetal (TSM) state.
- At fillings of ν = 0 and ν = ±2, the energies of the TIVC and TSM states become more stable as the EPC intensity increases.

### Conclusion

By constructing moiré optical phonon modes that are strongly coupled to flat bands, the authors successfully simplify the electron - phonon coupling problem in MATBG. These modes not only help to understand the strong vibration and inter - valley coherent signals observed in experiments, but also provide a new theoretical basis for future research on superconductivity and other related effects.