Electron-phonon coupling and competing Kekulé orders in twisted bilayer graphene

Yves H. Kwan,Glenn Wagner,Nick Bultinck,Steven H. Simon,Erez Berg,S.A. Parameswaran

2023-03-24

Abstract:Recent scanning tunneling microscopy experiments [K.P. Nuckolls et al., <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2303.00024" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.00024">arXiv:2303.00024</a>] have revealed the ubiquity of Kekulé charge-density wave order in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene. Most samples are moderately strained and show `incommensurate Kekulé spiral' (IKS) order involving a graphene-scale charge density distortion uniaxially modulated on the scale of the moiré superlattice, in accord with theoretical predictions. However, ultra-low strain samples instead show graphene-scale Kekulé charge order that is uniform on the moiré scale. This order, especially prominent near filling factor $\nu=-2$, is unanticipated by theory which predicts a time-reversal breaking Kekulé current order at low strain. We show that including the coupling of moiré electrons to graphene-scale optical zone-corner (ZC) phonons stabilizes a uniform Kekulé charge ordered state at $|\nu|=2$ with a quantized topological (spin or anomalous Hall) response. Our work clarifies how this phonon-driven selection of electronic order emerges in the strong-coupling regime of moiré graphene.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inconsistency between the Kekulé charge - density - wave order observed in Magic - Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene (MA - TBG) and theoretical predictions. Specifically:

1. **Differences between experimental observations and theoretical predictions**: Recent scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) experiments have revealed the prevalence of Kekulé charge - density - wave order in MA - TBG. Most samples exhibit "incommensurate Kekulé helix" (IKS) order under moderate strain, which is consistent with theoretical predictions. However, in samples with ultra - low strain, a uniform Kekulé charge order on the moiré scale was observed, especially near the filling factor \(\nu=- 2\). This phenomenon is inconsistent with the theoretically predicted time - reversal - symmetry - breaking Kekulé current order.

2. **Lack of theoretical explanation**: Theoretical predictions suggest that the Kekulé current order (KIVC) should occur under low strain, but experimental results show the Kekulé charge order (TIVC). This inconsistency requires a reasonable theoretical explanation.

3. **The role of electron - phonon coupling**: The paper proposes that by considering the coupling (EPC) between electrons and graphene - scale optical - zone - corner (ZC) phonons, it is possible to explain why a uniform Kekulé charge order is formed under low - strain conditions. Specifically, EPC can stabilize the uniform Kekulé charge - ordered state at \(\nu = 2\), and this state has a quantized topological response (spin or anomalous Hall response).

4. **Selection under strong - coupling mechanisms**: The paper further explores how EPC affects the selection of different electron - ordered states under strong - coupling mechanisms. Through numerical Hartree - Fock simulations, it studies how EPC interacts with other perturbations in the intermediate - coupling region to select specific ordered states.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to explain the inconsistency between the Kekulé charge - density - wave order observed in Magic - Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene and theoretical predictions by introducing the electron - phonon coupling mechanism, and to provide a unified theoretical framework to understand these experimental phenomena.