Flow Induced Corrosion in 6061-T6 Aluminum Pipes in De-Ionized Water Environments

Abhishek Deshpande,Erik Voirin

2023-11-30

Abstract:Flow induced corrosion/erosion of 6061-T6 aluminum in de-ionized (DI) water environments has not been studied widely. Especially, the long-term effects of corrosion/erosion in seemingly benign flow velocity, temperature, and resistivity ranges of 8 ft/s, 85 oF, 3-5 MOhm-cm, respectively. This study concludes that the flow induced corrosion/erosion in the above parameter ranges is minimal. This is detailed by presenting a literature survey, measuring pipe wall samples from a system that has operated in the above parameter range, predict the loss of material in mm/year at the above velocities and at higher temperatures using electric potential values from other experimental studies coupled with wall shear stress simulated using Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) analysis.

Accelerator Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **the corrosion/erosion problem of 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy in deionized water environment caused by fluid flow**, especially the influence within the seemingly mild range of flow rate, temperature and resistivity (8 feet/second, 85°F, 3 - 5 MOhm - cm respectively).

Specifically, the research aims to evaluate the following issues:
1. **Long - term influence**: Whether the long - term corrosion/erosion influence of fluid flow on 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy pipes is significant within the above - mentioned parameter range.
2. **Material loss prediction**: Predict the material loss rate (in mm/year) under these conditions through literature investigation, experimental measurement and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis, and estimate the material loss at higher temperatures.
3. **Practical operation experience**: Verify the theoretical prediction by analyzing the practical operation data of 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy pipes in the Fermi Laboratory Main Ring low - conductivity water (LCW) cooling system that have been used for more than 40 years.

### Main research content
1. **Literature review**: Review the research on the corrosion/erosion of aluminum alloys by high - flow - rate deionized water in the existing literature, although there are relatively few relevant literatures.
2. **Experimental measurement**: Measure the pipe wall samples taken from a long - running system to evaluate the actual material loss.
3. **CFD simulation**: Simulate the maximum wall - shear stress through CFD analysis and combine the potential values in other experimental studies to predict material loss.
4. **Practical operation experience**: Analyze the operation experience of 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy pipes in the Fermi Laboratory Main Ring LCW cooling system, which has been in operation for more than 40 years.

### Research conclusions
The research shows that within the above - mentioned parameter range, the corrosion/erosion of 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy pipes caused by fluid flow is very slight. Specifically:
- CFD simulation shows that the wall - shear stress in the worst - case scenario is only 50 Pa.
- Estimated using the data of two experimental devices, the material loss within 35 years is extremely small, and the maximum material loss in one case is 2.22 mm (0.087 inches).
- Practical operation experience shows that the pipes that have been in operation for more than 40 years have almost no corrosion damage.

Therefore, it can be expected that the 6061 - T6 aluminum alloy components in the LBNF absorber will experience very little corrosion/erosion during their approximately 35 - year operating life.

### Formula summary
The formulas involved in the paper are as follows:

1. **Corrosion current density**:
\[
I_{\text{corr}}=\frac{V}{R}
\]
where \( V \) is the corrosion potential and \( R \) is the charge - transfer impedance.

2. **Corrosion rate**:
\[
W_{\text{loss}}=\frac{I_{\text{corr}}M_{\text{Al}}}{n_{\text{cl}}F_c}
\]
where \( M_{\text{Al}} \) is the molar mass of aluminum, \( n_{\text{cl}} \) is the valence of aluminum, and \( F_c \) is the Faraday constant.

3. **Annual material loss rate**:
\[
L_{\text{corr}}=\frac{W_{\text{loss}}}{\rho_{\text{Al}}A_{\text{wall}}}
\]
where \( \rho_{\text{Al}} \) is the density of aluminum and \( A_{\text{wall}} \) is the wall area.

4. **Total material loss within 35 years**:
\[
T_{\text{loss}} = L_{\text{corr}}\times35\text{ years}
\]

These formulas are used to quantify the corrosion rate and material loss, thus supporting the research conclusions.