Field momentum and the reality of the Dirac String

Siva Mythili Gonuguntla,Douglas Singleton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.108.075005

2023-10-10

Abstract:It is well known that a magnetic monopole-electric charge system carries an angular momentum in its electromagnetic fields. Here we show that in the Dirac string formulation of magnetic charge the monopole-electric charge system also carries a momentum in its electromagnetic fields. This overlooked field momentum arises from the Coulomb electric field of the electric charge and the solenoidal magnetic field of the Dirac string. This implies that the monopole-charge system must either: (i) carry a ``hidden momentum" in the string, indicating that the string is real, or (ii) that the monopole-charge system violates the center-of-energy theorem. The overall conclusion is that the Dirac monopole with a {\it regulated} Dirac string is not a true monopole, and is not even a good effective description for topological monopoles ({\it e.g.} the 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole outside the core).

High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the electromagnetic field momentum in the magnetic monopole - charge system with respect to the Dirac string. Specifically, the paper explores the following points:

1. **Angular momentum and momentum of the magnetic monopole - charge system**: It is known that the magnetic monopole - charge system carries angular momentum in its electromagnetic field. This paper further shows that in the magnetic charge system described by the Dirac string, this system also carries electromagnetic field momentum. This overlooked field momentum originates from the Coulomb electric field of the charge and the solenoid magnetic field of the Dirac string.

2. **Physical reality of the Dirac string**: According to the analysis in the paper, if the magnetic monopole - charge system carries this overlooked field momentum, one of the following two situations must be satisfied:
- (i) The system carries "hidden momentum", which means that the Dirac string is physically real.
- (ii) The system violates the center - of - energy theorem. However, the second situation is generally considered unacceptable because it violates the basic principles of special relativity.

3. **Validity issue of the Dirac monopole**: The final conclusion is that the Dirac monopole with the adjusted Dirac string is not a true monopole and cannot even well describe topological monopoles (such as the 't Hooft - Polyakov monopole in the outer core region).

### Formula summary

The key formulas involved in the paper include:

- Expression for the magnetic field:
\[
B = \lim_{\epsilon \to 0} \nabla \times (A_{\text{reg}}^{\pm}) = \frac{g \hat{r}}{r^2} \pm 4\pi g \delta(x) \delta(y) \Theta(\mp z) \hat{z}
\]

- Calculation of electromagnetic field momentum:
\[
P_{\text{point}}^{\text{EM}} = \frac{1}{4\pi} \int (\mathbf{E} \times \mathbf{B}) d^3x = 0
\]
\[
P_{\text{string}}^{\text{EM}} = \frac{1}{4\pi} \int \left( \frac{q \hat{r}'}{r'^2} \times \left( \pm 4\pi g \delta(x) \delta(y) \Theta(\mp z) \hat{z} \right) \right) d^3x
\]
\[
P_{\text{string}}^{\text{EM}} = \pm g q \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \Theta(\mp z) \frac{x_0 \hat{y} - y_0 \hat{x}}{(\rho_0^2 + (z - z_0)^2)^{3/2}} dz = \frac{g q r_0 \mp z_0}{r_0 \rho_0^2} (-y_0 \hat{x} + x_0 \hat{y})
\]

- Calculation of hidden mechanical momentum:
\[
P_{\text{hid}}^{\text{mech}} = - \int \phi \mathbf{J} d^3x
\]
\[
P_{\text{hid}}^{\text{mech}} = - g q x_0 \int_{-\infty}^{0} \frac{dz \hat{y}}{(x_0^2 + (z - z_0)^2)^{3/2}} = - g q \frac{r_0 - z_0}{r_0 x_0} \hat{y}
\]

Through these formulas, the paper shows the contribution of the Dirac string to the electromagnetic field momentum and presents a new perspective to understand magnetic monopoles and their related phenomena.