Abstract:[Background] The proton charge radius extracted from recent muonic hydrogen Lamb shift measurements is significantly smaller than that extracted from atomic hydrogen and electron scattering measurements. [Purpose] In an attempt to understand the discrepancy, we review high-precision electron scattering results from Mainz, Jefferson Lab, Saskatoon and Stanford. [Method] We make use of stepwise regression techniques using the $F$-test as well as the Akaike information criterion to systematically determine the predictive variables to use for a given set and range of electron scattering data as well as to provide multivariate error estimates. [Results] Starting with the precision, low four-momentum transfer ($Q^2$) data from Mainz (1980) and Saskatoon (1974), we find that a stepwise regression of the Maclaurin series using the $F$-test as well as the Akaike information criterion justify using a linear extrapolation which yields a value for the proton radius that is consistent with the result obtained from muonic hydrogen measurements. Applying the same Maclaurin series and statistical criteria to the 2014 Rosenbluth results on $G_E$ from Mainz, we again find that the stepwise regression tends to favor a radius consistent with the muonic hydrogen radius but produces results that are extremely sensitive to the range of data included in the fit. Making use of the high-$Q^2$ data on $G_E$ to select functions which extrapolate to high $Q^2$, we find that a Padé ($N=M=1$) statistical model works remarkably well, as does a dipole function with a 0.84 fm radius, $G_E(Q^2) = ( 1 + Q^2/0.66\,\mathrm{GeV}^2)^{-2}$. [Conclusions] From this statistical analysis, we conclude that the electron scattering result and the muonic hydrogen result are consistent. It is the atomic hydrogen results that are the outliers.

Fitting for the energy levels of hydrogen

A tabulation of the bound-state energies of atomic hydrogen

Relativistic Ritz approach to hydrogen-like atoms I: theoretical considerations

Prospects for the determination of fundamental constants with beyond-state-of-the-art uncertainty using molecular hydrogen ion spectroscopy

Precision-Spectroscopic Determination of the Binding Energy of a Two-Body Quantum System: The Hydrogen Atom and the Proton-Size Puzzle

The Proton Radius from Electron Scattering Data

Method for precision measurement of the Range -- Energy relation for protons in pure hydrogen gas

Hydrogen and hydrogen-like-ion bound states and hyperfine splittings: finite nuclear size effects}

Hydrogen energy levels from the anomalous energy-momentum QED trace

Precision Rydberg State Spectroscopy with Slow Electrons and Proton Radius Puzzle

The Charge Radius of the Proton

A measurement of the atomic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton charge radius

Relativistic corrections to energy spectrum of hydrogen due to the full one-photon-exchange interaction

Metrology of Rydberg states of the hydrogen atom

Theory of Light Hydrogenlike Atoms

Integrals for relativistic nonadiabatic energies of H$_2$ in exponential basis

Finite nuclear mass correction to the hyperfine splitting in hydrogenic systems

Proton size from precision experiments on hydrogen and muonic hydrogen atoms

Lamb shift of $n = 1$ and $n = 2$ states of hydrogenlike atoms, $1 \le Z \le 110$

Metaplectic-c Quantized Energy Levels of the Hydrogen Atom

High-precision solution of the Dirac Equation for the hydrogen molecular ion using a basis-set expansion