Proton size from precision experiments on hydrogen and muonic hydrogen atoms

D. Solovyev,T. Zalialiutdinov,A. Anikin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2009.11520

2021-03-29

Abstract:The "proton radius puzzle" was recently solved by reducing the four-standard deviation discrepancy between the results for electronic hydrogen ($H$) and muonic hydrogen ($\mu H$) atoms to $3.3$ value. The value of the root-mean-square radius of the proton ($r_p$), extracted from experiments on measuring the one-photon $2s-4p$ transition and the Lamb shift in hydrogen, is now $0.8335(95)$ fm, that is in good agreement with the muonic hydrogen experiments, $0.84087(39)$ fm. Even so, these values deviate significantly from the CODATA value, which is determined as the average using the results for various spectral lines including two-photon transitions in the hydrogen atom. The solution of the proton radius puzzle was realized by taking into account the influence of interference effect in one-photon scattering processes. The importance of interfering effects in atomic frequencies measurements gives an impetus to the study of experiments based on two-photon spectroscopy with the suchlike thoroughness. It is shown here that the effect of interfering pathways for two-photon $2s-nd$ transitions in a hydrogen atom is also significant in determining the proton charge radius and Rydberg constant.

Atomic Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the so - called "proton radius puzzle". Specifically, this problem stems from the significant difference between the root - mean - square proton radii ($ r_p $) measured in electron - hydrogen atom (H) and muonic - hydrogen atom ($ \mu H $) experiments. Early studies showed that the proton radius obtained from electron - hydrogen atom experiments differed from that obtained from muonic - hydrogen atom experiments by more than four standard deviations, which has triggered extensive discussions and research in the physics community. By considering the interference effect in the single - photon scattering process, the paper reduced the difference between the proton radius $ r_p = 0.8335(95) $ fm measured in electron - hydrogen atom experiments and $ r_p = 0.84087(39) $ fm measured in muonic - hydrogen atom experiments to 3.3 standard deviations. Nevertheless, these values still differ significantly from the CODATA - recommended average value $ r_p = 0.8751(61) $ fm. To further solve this problem, the paper analyzed in detail the influence of nonresonant effects in the two - photon transition process (such as 2s - nd transition) in hydrogen atoms, and pointed out that these effects are of great significance in determining the proton charge radius and the Rydberg constant. By introducing the quantum interference effect (QIE), the paper re - evaluated the relevant experimental data and proposed new values for the proton radius and the Rydberg constant. In conclusion, through in - depth analysis and consideration of various nonresonant effects, this paper provides a new perspective and method for solving the "proton radius puzzle".

Proton size from precision experiments on hydrogen and muonic hydrogen atoms

Proton Radius: A Puzzle or a Solution!?

A measurement of the atomic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton charge radius

Extraction of the proton charge radius from experiments

Determining the size of the proton

Review of experimental and theoretical status of the proton radius puzzle

The Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen and the electric rms radius of the proton

The Proton Radius from Electron Scattering Data

Precision Rydberg State Spectroscopy with Slow Electrons and Proton Radius Puzzle

The Charge Radius of the Proton

Precision-Spectroscopic Determination of the Binding Energy of a Two-Body Quantum System: The Hydrogen Atom and the Proton-Size Puzzle

Polynomial fits and the proton radius puzzle

Brief review of the theory of the muonic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton radius

Proton structure from the measurement of 2S-2P transition frequencies of muonic hydrogen

The alpha particle charge radius, the radion and the proton radius puzzle

The alpha and helion particle charge radius difference from spectroscopy of quantum-degenerate helium

Nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in $μ^3$He$^+$ and $μ^3$H

Prospects for the determination of fundamental constants with beyond-state-of-the-art uncertainty using molecular hydrogen ion spectroscopy

Determination of the moments of the proton charge density: is there a proton radius puzzle?

Nonidentical protons

Direct comparison of using a Z-transformation instead of the traditional for extraction of the proton radius from scattering data