Evaluating The Impact Of Species Specialisation On Ecological Network Robustness Using Analytic Methods

Chris Jones,Damaris Zurell,Karoline Wiesner

2023-07-05

Abstract:Ecological networks describe the interactions between different species, informing us of how they rely on one another for food, pollination and survival. If a species in an ecosystem is under threat of extinction, it can affect other species in the system and possibly result in their secondary extinction as well. Understanding how (primary) extinctions cause secondary extinctions on ecological networks has been considered previously using computational methods. However, these methods do not provide an explanation for the properties which make ecological networks robust, and can be computationally expensive. We develop a new analytic model for predicting secondary extinctions which requires no non-deterministic computational simulation. Our model can predict secondary extinctions when primary extinctions occur at random or due to some targeting based on the number of links per species or risk of extinction, and can be applied to an ecological network of any number of layers. Using our model, we consider how false positives and negatives in network data affect predictions for network robustness. We have also extended the model to predict scenarios in which secondary extinctions occur once species lose a certain percentage of interaction strength, and to model the loss of interactions as opposed to just species extinction. From our model, it is possible to derive new analytic results such as how ecological networks are most robust when secondary species degree variance is minimised. Additionally, we show that both specialisation and generalisation in distribution of interaction strength can be advantageous for network robustness, depending upon the extinction scenario being considered.

Populations and Evolution,Combinatorics,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of species specialisation on the robustness of ecological networks and propose a new analytical model to predict secondary extinctions. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Understanding the robustness of ecological networks**:
- Ecological networks describe the interactions between different species, including food, pollination, and survival - dependence relationships. If a species is threatened with extinction, it may affect other species and lead to secondary extinctions.
- Previous studies mainly relied on computational methods to simulate the impact of species extinctions, but these methods could not explain the properties that make ecological networks robust and were computationally expensive.

2. **Developing a new analytical model**:
- The paper has developed a new analytical model that can predict secondary extinctions without the need for non - deterministic computational simulations.
- This model can handle random or targeted primary extinctions based on the number of species links or extinction risks and is applicable to ecological networks of any number of layers.

3. **Evaluating the impact of data errors**:
- The study also explored how false positives and false negatives in network data affect the prediction of network robustness.
- The model has been extended to consider the situation where secondary extinctions occur when species lose a certain proportion of interaction intensity, rather than just the species extinction itself.

4. **Revealing the topological properties of ecological network robustness**:
- Using this model, the authors demonstrated that when the variance of the secondary species - degree distribution is minimised, the ecological network is most robust to random extinctions.
- When considering the interaction intensity, it was found that both highly specialised and highly generalised interaction intensity distributions can improve the robustness of the network, depending on the extinction scenario.

Through these studies, the paper aims to provide a deeper understanding, help identify and strengthen the robustness of ecosystems, and thus provide theoretical support for future ecological protection and restoration work.

### Formula summary

- **Robustness formula**:
\[
R = 1-\frac{1}{N_p}\sum_{\varphi = 0}^{N_p}\Pr(\text{extinct}|\varphi)
\]
where \(N_p\) is the total number of primary species, \(\varphi\) is the number of already - extinct primary species, and \(\Pr(\text{extinct}|\varphi)\) is the average extinction probability of secondary species after \(\varphi\) primary species have become extinct.

- **Probability of secondary species - degree distribution change**:
\[
\Pr(k'_A=k_A - j|\varphi)=
\begin{cases}
\frac{\binom{k_A}{j}\binom{N_p - k_A}{\varphi - j}}{\binom{N_p}{\varphi}}, &\text{if }\varphi\geq j,\\
0, &\text{otherwise}
\end{cases}
\]

- **Probability of secondary species extinction**:
\[
\Pr(A\text{ extinct}|\varphi)=\sum_{j = i_k}^{k_A}\Pr(k'_A=k_A - j|\varphi)
\]

- **Average probability of secondary species extinction**:
\[
\Pr(\text{extinct}|\varphi)=\sum_{k = 0}p(k)\sum_{j = i_k}^{k}\Pr(k'=k - j|\varphi)
\]

- **Absolute curve deviation**:
\[
D=\frac{1}{N_p}\sum_{\varphi = 0}^{N_p}|\Pr(\text{survive}|\varphi)_{\text{predict}}-\Pr(\text{survive}|\varphi)_{\text{actual}}|
\]