Synthesising the Relationships Between Food Web Structure and Robustness

Aislyn A. Keyes,Allison K. Barner,Laura E. Dee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ele.14533

IF: 11.274

2024-10-24

Ecology Letters

Abstract:Species are being lost from ecosystems, and for more than 20 years, ecologists have sought to understand the extent to which these species losses trigger secondary extinctions—that is, the additional loss of species following lost resources or key interactions—measured as robustness. We systematically reviewed 28 studies to identify the relationships between food web structures and robustness, and how the conclusions depend on methodological differences. More than 20 food web structures were reported to determine robustness, but the shape and direction of these relationships varied based on methodology. For many decades, ecologists have sought to understand the extent to which species losses lead to secondary extinctions—that is, the additional loss of species that occurs when resources or key interactions are lost (i.e. robustness). In particular, ecologists aim to identify generalisable rules that explain which types of food webs are more or less robust to secondary extinctions. Food web structure, or the patterns formed by species and their interactions, has been extensively studied as a potential factor that influences robustness to species loss. We systematically reviewed 28 studies to identify the relationships between food web structure and robustness to species loss and how the conclusions depend on methodological differences. Contrary to popular belief and theory, we found relatively consistent, positive relationships between connectance and robustness, among other generalities. Yet, we also found that conflicting conclusions about structure‐robustness relationships can be, in part, attributed to differences in the type of data that studies use, particularly studies that use empirical data versus those generated from theoretical models. This review points towards a need to standardise methodology to answer the open question of whether robustness and its relationship with food web structure and to provide applicable insights for managing complex systems.

ecology