The Trialkylsulfonium Cation Holds Promise to Capture Carbon Dioxide: In-Silico Evidence Toward a Novel Carbon Dioxide Scavenger

Vitaly V. Chaban

2023-05-05

Abstract:The concentration of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the Earth atmosphere is linked to the acute problem of global warming. For the first time, we herein introduce trialkylsulfonium aprotic ionic liquids (ILs) as a group of seemingly highly capacitive CO2 scavengers. We advocate the viability of the new sorbents by the reaction profiles recorded by means of hybrid density functional theory. All stages constituting CO2 chemisorption, such as the ethyldimethylsulfonium S211-cation deprotonation, S211-ylide carboxylation at the alpha-methylene group, and aprotic anion carboxamidation have been explored. The S211-ylide formation reaction is thermochemically forbidden but its cost is affordable. The energetic cost ranges from a tiny number of 14 kJ/mol for S211 indazolide to a mediocre value of 50 kJ/mol for S211 1,2,4-triazolide. The barriers corresponding to the sulfonium-based cation deprotonation range from 39 kJ/mol for benzimidazolide to +60 kJ/mol for 1,2,4-triazolide. The energy loss during the ylide intermediate formation is strongly compensated for by the subsequent sulfonium ylide carboxylation. The energetic gain is weakly dependent on the nature of the heterocyclic aprotic anion being 99 to 110 kJ/mol for different ionic species studied. The AHAs additionally participate in CO2 capture following the route of carboxamidation thanks to their nitrogen sites. The most thermochemically favorable carbamate forms out of S211-indazolide, 68 kJ/mol. The steric and covalent barriers associated with these reactions are of the order of thermal motion energy, whereas a specific chemical structure of AHA engenders marginal differences. The rationalization of the energy reaction profiles is given in terms of partial atomic charges, geometrical peculiarities, steric barriers, imaginary vibrational frequencies, and related descriptors.

Chemical Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore a new type of carbon dioxide capture agent - aprotic ionic liquids (ILs) based on trialkylsulfonium salts. Specifically, the authors introduced for the first time ionic liquids combining trialkylsulfonium cations with aprotic heterocyclic anions (AHAs) as high - performance carbon dioxide adsorbents. Through density functional theory (DFT) calculations, the key reaction steps involved in the chemisorption process of carbon dioxide were studied, such as the deprotonation of triethyldimethylsulfonium cations, the carboxylation of [S211] - imines, and the carbamation of aprotic anions. These studies aim to evaluate the thermodynamic and kinetic feasibility of this new type of adsorbent, in order to provide a theoretical basis for practical applications.

### Core problems of the paper
1. **Explore new carbon dioxide adsorbents**:
- Investigate whether ionic liquids based on trialkylsulfonium cations and aprotic heterocyclic anions can be used as efficient carbon dioxide adsorbents.
- Verify the thermodynamic and kinetic feasibility of these ionic liquids in the process of adsorbing carbon dioxide through theoretical calculations.

2. **Reaction mechanism research**:
- The key reaction steps such as the deprotonation of triethyldimethylsulfonium cations, the carboxylation of [S211] - imines, and the carbamation of aprotic anions were discussed in detail.
- Analyze the energy barriers and energy changes of these reactions to evaluate their feasibility in practical applications.

### Main findings
- **Deprotonation reaction**:
- The deprotonation energy barrier of triethyldimethylsulfonium cations is between 39 and 60 kJ/mol, depending on the type of anion.
- The thermodynamic cost of the deprotonation reaction is relatively low, ranging from 13 to 50 kJ/mol.

- **Carboxylation reaction**:
- The carboxylation reaction of [S211] - imines is an exothermic process, and the energy release ranges from - 99 to - 110 kJ/mol.
- This process can significantly compensate for the energy loss in the deprotonation reaction.

- **Carbamation reaction**:
- Aprotic anions participate in carbon dioxide capture through nitrogen atoms to form carbamates.
- The most favorable carbamate is formed in [S211] indazole salts, with an energy release of - 68 kJ/mol.

### Conclusions
- Through theoretical calculations, the potential of ionic liquids based on trialkylsulfonium cations and aprotic heterocyclic anions in carbon dioxide chemisorption has been confirmed.
- These ionic liquids show good performance both thermodynamically and kinetically, providing theoretical support for the development of new carbon dioxide capture agents.

### Formula examples
- **Deprotonation energy barrier**:
\[
\Delta E_{\text{deprotonation}} = E_{\text{transition state}} - E_{\text{initial state}}
\]
where \( E_{\text{transition state}} \) is the transition state energy of the deprotonation reaction, and \( E_{\text{initial state}} \) is the initial state energy.

- **Energy release in carboxylation reaction**:
\[
\Delta E_{\text{carboxylation}} = E_{\text{product}} - E_{\text{reactant}}
\]
where \( E_{\text{product}} \) is the energy of the carboxylation reaction product, and \( E_{\text{reactant}} \) is the energy of the reactant.

- **Energy release in carbamation reaction**:
\[
\Delta E_{\text{carbamation}} = E_{\text{carbamate}} - E_{\text{reactant}}
\]
where \( E_{\text{carbamate}} \) is the energy of the carbamate, and \( E_{\text{reactant}} \) is the energy of the reactant.

Through these studies, the paper provides an important theoretical basis and experimental guidance for the development of high - performance carbon dioxide capture agents.