Abstract:Ribet has proven remarkable results about non-optimal levels of residually reducible Galois representations. We focus on a non-optimal level $N$ that is the product of two distinct primes and where the Galois deformation ring is not expected to be Gorenstein. We prove a Galois-theoretic criterion for the deformation ring to be as small as possible -- that is, for there to be a unique newform of level $N$ with reducible residual representation. When this criterion is satisfied, we deduce an $R=\mathbb{T}$ theorem.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is a specific problem in the Galois representation theory of non - optimal levels. Specifically, the article focuses on the situation where the corresponding Galois deformation ring is not a Gorenstein ring when the non - optimal level \(N\) is the product of two different prime numbers.
### Specific problem description
1. **Background and motivation**:
- Ribet has already proven remarkable results regarding residually reducible Galois representations at non - optimal levels.
- This paper focuses on the non - optimal level \(N = \ell_0\ell_1\), where \(\ell_0\) and \(\ell_1\) are two different prime numbers, and the corresponding Galois deformation ring is expected not to be a Gorenstein ring.
2. **Research objectives**:
- Prove a Galois - theoretic criterion such that the deformation ring is as small as possible (i.e., there exists a unique newform with a reducible residual representation).
- When this criterion is satisfied, derive an \(R = T\) theorem, where \(R\) is the Galois pseudodeformation ring and \(T\) is the Hecke algebra acting on modular forms.
3. **Main assumptions and conditions**:
- \(p\geq5\) is a prime number.
- \(\ell_0\equiv1\ (\text{mod}\ p)\).
- \(\ell_1\not\equiv0,\pm1\ (\text{mod}\ p)\), and \(\ell_1\) is the \(p\)-th power of \(\ell_0\).
- There exists a unique cusp form \(f\) at level \(\ell_0\) that is congruent to the Eisenstein series modulo \(p\).
4. **Core problems**:
- Prove that under the above conditions, the \(\mathbb{F}_p\)-dimension of \(R / pR\) is greater than 3 if and only if certain specific invariants \(a(1)(Fr_{\ell_1}) = 0\) and \(\alpha^2+\beta = 0\).
- If one of these two conditions does not hold, then \(R\rightarrow T\) is an isomorphism, the \(\mathbb{Z}_p\)-rank of \(T\) is 3, and there exists a unique newform at level \(N\) that is congruent to the Eisenstein series modulo \(p\).
### Summary
This paper solves the difficult problem of proving \(R = T\) in the non - Gorenstein case by introducing new methods and techniques, especially by using second - order deformations and cup products and triple Massey products in Galois cohomology. This not only deepens the understanding of Galois representation theory but also provides prototypes and tools for broader situations.