Abstract:Some sigma models which admit a theta angle are integrable at both $\vartheta=0$ and $\vartheta=\pi$. This includes the well-known $O(3)$ sigma model and two families of coset sigma models studied by Fendley. We consider the ground state energy of these models in the presence of a magnetic field, which can be computed with the Bethe ansatz. We obtain explicit results for its non-perturbative corrections and we study the effect of the theta angle on them. We show that imaginary, exponentially small corrections due to renormalons remain unchanged, while instanton corrections change sign, as expected. We find in addition corrections due to renormalons which also change sign as we turn on the theta angle. Based on these results we present an explicit non-perturbative formula for the topological susceptibility of the $O(3)$ sigma model in the presence of a magnetic field, in the weak coupling limit.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study how non - perturbative effects (such as instanton and renormalon effects) change with the θ - angle in integrable sigma models with a θ - angle, especially in the O(3) sigma model and its related models. Specifically, the author focuses on the ground - state energy of these models in the presence of a magnetic field and calculates their non - perturbative corrections through the Bethe ansatz method. The main objectives of the paper are: 1. **Study the influence of the θ - angle on non - perturbative effects**: In particular, the author hopes to understand how the instanton correction changes sign with the θ - angle and whether the real part of the renormalon correction also changes sign with the θ - angle. 2. **Provide specific formulas for non - perturbative effects**: The author attempts to give non - perturbative formulas for the topological susceptibility in the weak - coupling limit of the O(3) sigma model in the presence of a magnetic field. 3. **Verify the analysis results**: Verify the correctness of the theoretical predictions through detailed numerical studies, especially the numerical analysis of the Bethe ansatz equation. ### Main content of the paper #### 1. Introduction - **Background**: Introduces the importance of non - perturbative effects in quantum field theory, especially instanton and renormalon effects. - **Motivation**: Proposes to better understand these effects, especially the influence of the θ - angle, by studying non - perturbative effects in integrable models. #### 2. O(3) sigma model at θ = 0 - **Free energy**: Defines the free energy in the presence of a magnetic field and gives its calculation method. - **Non - perturbative corrections**: Discusses in detail the calculation of non - perturbative corrections, including instanton and renormalon effects. #### 3. O(3) sigma model at θ = π - **Free energy**: Describes the method for calculating the free energy of the O(3) sigma model at θ = π. - **Non - perturbative corrections**: Analyzes the non - perturbative corrections at θ = π, especially the changes in instanton and renormalon effects. - **Numerical verification**: Verifies the correctness of the theoretical results through numerical analysis. #### 4. Fendley's integrable models - **General properties**: Introduces two families of integrable models proposed by Fendley. - **Non - perturbative effects**: Studies the non - perturbative effects of these models at θ = 0 and θ = π. - **Numerical verification**: Verifies the theoretical predictions through numerical analysis. #### 5. Discussion and future prospects - **Conclusion**: Summarizes the main findings, especially the influence of the θ - angle on non - perturbative effects. - **Future work**: Proposes directions for further research, such as more complex models and higher - order corrections. ### Main findings - **Instanton correction**: In the O(3) sigma model, the sign of the instanton correction changes with the θ - angle, which is as expected. - **Renormalon correction**: The imaginary part of the renormalon correction remains unchanged, but its real part changes sign with the θ - angle. - **Topological susceptibility**: Gives a non - perturbative formula for the topological susceptibility in the weak - coupling limit of the O(3) sigma model in the presence of a magnetic field. ### Mathematical formulas - **Integral equation of free energy**: \[ \epsilon(\theta)-\int_{-B}^{B} K(\theta-\theta')\epsilon(\theta')d\theta'=h - m\cosh(\theta),\quad\theta\in[-B, B] \] - **Expression of free energy**: \[ F(h)=-\frac{m}{2\pi}\int_{-B}^{B}\epsilon(\theta)\cosh(\theta)d\theta \] - **Decomposition of renormalon function**: \[ \sigma(\omega)=\frac{G_-(\omega)}{G_+(\omega)} \] Through these studies, the author provides an in - depth understanding of non - perturbative effects under the influence of the θ - angle, providing an important reference for future theoretical and experimental research.

Instantons, renormalons and the theta angle in integrable sigma models

On the infrared limit of the O(3) nonlinear $σ$-model at $θ= π$

Classical Integrability of the O(N) Nonlinear Sigma Model on a Half-Line

Winding theta and destructive interference of instantons

Fractionally charged Wilson loops as a probe of $θ$-dependence in $CP^{N-1}$ sigma models: Instantons vs. large N

The $J_1$-$J_2$ spin chain and the $O(3)$ non-linear sigma model at $θ= π$

Sigma model instantons and singular tau function

Wiener-Hopf solution of the free energy TBA problem and instanton sectors in the O(3) sigma model

Critical behaviour of the O(3) nonlinear sigma model with topological term at theta=pi from numerical simulations

An Infinite Family of Integrable Sigma Models Using Auxiliary Fields

Refined instanton analysis of the 2D $\mathbb{C}P^{N-1}$ model: mass gap, theta dependence, and mirror symmetry

Monte Carlo study of Schwinger model without the sign problem

Classical and quantum integrable sigma models. Ricci flow, "nice duality" and perturbed rational conformal field theories

Infinite Family of Integrable Sigma Models Using Auxiliary Fields

Nonlinear sigma models for monitored dynamics of free fermions

Tensor network simulation of the ( 1 + 1 )-dimensional O ( 3 ) nonlinear σ -model with θ = π term

Topological Insulators And Topological Nonlinear Sigma Models

Functional Renormalization Group Analysis of $O(3)$ Nonlinear Sigma Model and Non-Abelian Bosonization Duality

Tensor renormalization group study of (1+1)-dimensional O(3) nonlinear sigma model with and without finite chemical potential

Instantons and the Large N=4 Algebra

Self-dual Models with Theta Terms