Refined instanton analysis of the 2D $\mathbb{C}P^{N-1}$ model: mass gap, theta dependence, and mirror symmetry

Mendel Nguyen,Mithat Ünsal

2023-09-21

Abstract:We address nonperturbative dynamics of the two-dimensional bosonic and supersymmetric $\mathbb{C}P^{N-1}$ models for general $N$ by developing new tools directly on $\mathbb{R}^2$. The analysis starts with a new formulation of instantons that is consistent with the existence of the classical moduli space, classical dipole--dipole type interactions of instanton--anti-instanton pairs, and vanishing interaction of instanton--instanton pairs. The classical consistency is achieved via a representation of the instanton as a collection of $N$ pointlike constituents carrying pair of real and imaginary charges valued in the weight lattice of $SU(N)$. The constituents interact via a generalized Coulomb interaction and do not violate the fact that instanton is a single lump with integer topological charge. By developing the appropriate Gibbs distribution, we show that the vacuum can be captured by a statistical field theory of these constituents, and their cluster expansion. Contrary to the common belief that instantons do not capture the vacuum structure and non-perturbation properties of such theories, our refined analysis is able to produce properties such as mass gap, theta dependence, and confinement of the theory on $\mathbb{R}^2$. In supersymmetric theory, our construction gives a new derivation of the mirror symmetry between the sigma model and the dual Landau--Ginzburg model by Hori and Vafa. Our construction also demonstrates that there is absolutely no conflict between large $N$ and instantons.

High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the non - perturbative analysis of instanton dynamics in the two - dimensional CPN - 1 model. Specifically, the authors have developed new tools to directly study these models on R², and capture the vacuum structure and non - perturbative properties through an improved instanton gas model. The main objectives include:

1. **Mass Gap**: Study how to correctly describe the mass gap of the theory through instanton analysis.
2. **Theta Dependence**: Explore the theta dependence of the multi - branch structure in the theory.
3. **Mirror Symmetry**: In the supersymmetric theory, re - derive the mirror symmetry results of Hori and Vafa by non - supersymmetric tools.

### Main contributions of the paper

1. **New description of instanton moduli space**:
- The authors propose a new method for describing the instanton moduli space, using the concept of "pseudoconstituents". Each instanton is regarded as being composed of N point - like objects, which carry real and imaginary charges, and these charges take values in the weight lattice of SU(N).

2. **Classical instanton interactions**:
- The authors discuss in detail the dipole - dipole interaction between instanton - anti - instanton pairs, and the vanishing of the interaction between instanton - instanton pairs. By introducing real and imaginary charges, these interactions can be correctly described.

3. **Appropriate Gibbs distribution**:
- The authors construct an appropriate Gibbs distribution for describing the statistical field theory of instanton pseudoconstituents. This makes it possible to capture the vacuum structure through cluster expansion.

4. **Sub - leading contributions**:
- The authors consider the sub - leading contributions in the cluster expansion, which are crucial for correctly describing non - perturbative properties.

### Main conclusions

- **Mass Gap**: Through the improved instanton gas model, the authors are able to correctly describe the mass gap of the theory.
- **Theta Dependence**: The authors show how the multi - branch theta dependence emerges from instanton analysis.
- **Mirror Symmetry**: In the supersymmetric theory, the authors re - derive the mirror symmetry results of Hori and Vafa by non - supersymmetric tools.

### Formula summary

1. **Instanton - instanton interaction**:
\[
U_{II} \propto (1, +i) \cdot (1, +i) = 0
\]

2. **Instanton - anti - instanton interaction**:
\[
U_{II} \propto (1, +i) \cdot (1, -i) \neq 0
\]

3. **Dipole - dipole interaction**:
\[
U_{ij} = \left( \nu_i, i\nu_i \right) \cdot \left( -\nu_j, i\nu_j \right) G(a_i - b_j, a_i - b_j) = \frac{4\pi}{Ng^2} (-\nu_i \cdot \nu_j) (-\log |a_i - b_j|^2)
\]

4. **Operators in Gibbs distribution**:
\[
V_i \sim e^{-y_i} = e^{-\rho_i + i\theta_i} \quad (i = 1, \ldots, N)
\]

5. **Mean - field equation**:
\[
\frac{\delta S_{\text{eff}}}{\delta y_i} = 0 \implies \langle e^{-y_i(x)} \rangle = e^{-\frac{I}{N} + i\left(\frac{\theta + 2\pi k}{N}\right)}
\]

Through these improvements, the authors have successfully challenged the traditional pessimistic view that instantons are unimportant in the large - N limit, and proved that instantons can provide a reliable description of non - perturbative physics.