Winding theta and destructive interference of instantons

Mendel Nguyen,Yuya Tanizaki,Mithat Ünsal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP09%282023%29033

2023-07-19

Abstract:While the $\theta$ dependence of field theories is $2\pi$ periodic, the ground-state wavefunctions at $\theta$ and $\theta+2\pi$ often belong to different classes of symmetry-protected topological states. When this is the case, a continuous change of the $\theta$ parameter can introduce an interface that supports a nontrivial field theory localized on the wall. We consider the $2$d $\mathbb{C}P^{N-1}$ sigma model as an example and construct a weak-coupling setup of this interface theory by considering the small $S^1$ compactification with nonzero winding $\theta$ parameter and a suitable symmetry-twisted boundary condition. This system has $N$ classical vacua connected by fractional instantons, but the anomaly constraint tells us that the fractional-instanton amplitudes should vanish completely to have $N$-fold degeneracy at the quantum level. We show how this happens in this purely bosonic system, uncovering that the integration over the zero modes annihilates the fractional instanton amplitudes, which is sharp contrast to what happens when the $\theta$ angle is constant. Moreover, we provide another explanation of this selection rule by showing that the $N$ perturbative vacua acquire different charges under the global symmetry with the activation of the winding $\theta$ angle. We also demonstrate a similar destructive interference between instanton effects in the $\mathbb{C}P^{N-1}$ quantum mechanics with the Berry phase.

High Energy Physics - Theory,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore how instanton effects lead to destructive interference when the θ parameter has a non - zero winding number in the two - dimensional CPN - 1 model, and explain how this interference maintains the N - fold degeneracy at the quantum level. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following problems:

1. **Understanding the role of instantons under different θ conditions**:
- For a constant θ value (θ ≠ π), fractional instantons will increase the degeneracy of the classical vacuum, resulting in a unique ground state.
- For θ with a non - zero winding number (winding θ), due to the anomaly constraint, the quantum vacuum should have N - fold degeneracy. The paper explores how, in this case, the instanton amplitude completely disappears, thus maintaining the N - fold degeneracy.

2. **Analyzing the influence of instanton zero - modes on the instanton amplitude**:
- Through the analysis of the dilute (fractional) instanton gas in the weak - coupling region, the paper finds that a specific instanton zero - mode direction will affect the instanton amplitude and introduce a purely imaginary term during the integration process.
- This integration causes the transition amplitude between all adjacent classical vacuums to completely disappear, that is:
\[
\langle k + 1|e^{-\beta\hat{H}}|k\rangle\approx
\begin{cases}
e^{-S_I/N + i\theta/N}\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi^* & \text{constant }\theta\\
e^{-S_I/N + i\bar{\theta}/N}\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi^*e^{iw\phi^*} = 0 & \text{winding }\theta
\end{cases}
\]
where \(\phi^*\) is a bosonic zero - mode of the fractional instanton.

3. **Explaining the selection rules in Hilbert space**:
- When θ has a non - zero winding number, the state \(|k\rangle\) acquires a non - trivial charge of the Up(1)_{N - 1}/Z_N symmetry, while these states are neutral under a constant θ.
- Applying the Noether theorem, a simple formula can be obtained:
\[
\hat{Q}|k\rangle = wk|k\rangle
\]
where \(w\) is the winding number. This is similar to the Witten effect, in which magnetic - charge particles acquire a charge after a constant θ angle is turned on.

4. **Providing basic examples in quantum mechanics**:
- The paper shows, through examples in quantum mechanics, how the Berry phase leads to destructive interference between different instanton paths, thus keeping the N - fold degeneracy unchanged.
- This example not only illustrates the phenomenon of destructive interference but also serves as an example of the interface theory between two different SPT states.

5. **Discussing generalized symmetries and anomalies**:
- The paper discusses in detail the generalized mixed anomalies in the 2d CPN - 1 model, especially the relationship between the PSU(N) symmetry and the θ - periodicity.
- By introducing a background gauge field, the paper shows the topological phase transition at θ = π in the system and how these phase transitions affect the low - energy dynamics of the system.

Overall, through detailed theoretical analysis and specific calculations, this paper reveals how instanton effects lead to destructive interference and maintain the N - fold degeneracy at the quantum level when the θ parameter has a non - zero winding number. This research is of great significance for understanding topological effects and symmetry - protected topological phases in quantum field theory.