Nonlinear sigma models for monitored dynamics of free fermions

Michele Fava,Lorenzo Piroli,Tobias Swann,Denis Bernard,Adam Nahum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.13.041045

2023-12-09

Abstract:We derive field theory descriptions for measurement-induced phase transitions in free fermion systems. We focus on a multi-flavor Majorana chain, undergoing Hamiltonian evolution with continuous monitoring of local fermion parity operators. Using the replica trick, we map the dynamics to the imaginary time evolution of an effective spin chain, and use the number of flavors as a large parameter for a controlled derivation of the effective field theory. This is a nonlinear sigma model for an orthogonal $N\times N$ matrix, in the replica limit $N\to 1$. (On a boundary of the phase diagram, another sigma model with higher symmetry applies.) Together with known results for the renormalization-group beta function, this derivation establishes the existence of stable phases -- nontrivially entangled and disentangled respectively -- in the physically-relevant replica limit $N\to 1$. In the nontrivial phase, an asymptotically exact calculation shows that the bipartite entanglement entropy for a system of size $L$ scales as $(\log L)^2$, in contrast to findings in previously-studied models. Varying the relative strength of Hamiltonian evolution and monitoring, as well as a dimerization parameter, the model's phase diagram contains transitions out of the nontrivial phase, which we map to vortex-unbinding transitions in the sigma model, and also contains separate critical points on the measurement-only axis. We highlight the close analogies as well as the differences with the replica approach to Anderson transitions in disordered systems.

Statistical Mechanics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the theoretical description of measurement-induced phase transitions in free fermion systems under continuous monitoring. Specifically, the authors focus on the behavior of a multi-flavor Majorana chain under the combined influence of Hamiltonian dynamics and continuous monitoring of local fermion parity operators.

### Main Research Questions:
1. **Field Theory Description of Measurement-Induced Phase Transitions**:
- How to use the replica trick to map the system's dynamics to an effective spin chain and further derive a nonlinear σ model (NLσM).
- In the physically relevant replica limit \( N \to 1 \), how to establish the existence of stable phases, including non-trivial entangled phases and disentangled phases.

2. **Scaling Behavior of Entanglement Entropy**:
- In the non-trivial phase, whether the scaling behavior of bipartite entanglement entropy with system size \( L \) follows the form \((\ln L)^2\).
- How the phase transitions in the system's phase diagram, induced by varying the relative strength of Hamiltonian dynamics and monitoring, as well as the dimerization parameter, are mapped to vortex unbinding transitions in the NLσM.

3. **Analogy with Anderson Localization**:
- What are the similarities and differences between the effective field theory obtained and the nonlinear σ model in the Anderson localization problem.
- Specifically, in the limit \( N \to 1 \), how to interpret the analogy between entanglement in the measurement problem and conductivity in Anderson localization.

### Research Methods:
- **Replica Trick**: Introducing multiple replicas to average the results of random measurements, thereby obtaining an effective Hamiltonian.
- **Field Theory Mapping**: Mapping the dynamics of the replica system to a spin chain and further deriving a nonlinear σ model.
- **Renormalization Group Analysis**: Using renormalization group methods to analyze the critical exponents of phase transitions and the topological structure of the phase diagram.

### Main Results:
- **Non-Trivial Entangled Phase**: In the non-trivial phase, the scaling behavior of bipartite entanglement entropy with system size \( L \) is \((\ln L)^2\), which differs from previously studied models.
- **Phase Diagram Structure**: By varying the relative strength of Hamiltonian dynamics and monitoring, as well as the dimerization parameter, continuous phase transitions from the non-trivial phase to the area law phase exist in the system's phase diagram.
- **Vortex Unbinding Transition**: The phase transition can be mapped to a vortex unbinding transition in the NLσM, providing a deep understanding of the phase transition mechanism.

### Significance:
- This study provides a new theoretical framework for understanding the dynamical behavior of free fermion systems under continuous monitoring.
- By establishing an analogy with Anderson localization, it offers a new perspective for studying measurement-induced phase transitions.
- The results of this study are of significant importance for related problems in quantum information science and condensed matter physics.