Abstract:Perceptual similarity is one of the most fiercely debated topics in the philosophy and psychology of perception. The documented history of the issue spans all the way from Plato – who regarded similarity as a key factor for human perceptual experience and cognition – through to contemporary psychologists – who have tried to determine whether, and if so, how similarity relationships can be established between stimuli both within and across the senses. Recent research on cross-sensory associations, otherwise known as crossmodal correspondences – that is, the existence of observable consensual associations, or mappings, between stimuli across different senses – represents an especially interesting field in which to study perceptual similarity. In fact, most accounts of crossmodal association that have been put forward in the literature to date evoke perceptual similarity as a key explanatory factor mediating the underlying association. At the same time, however, these various accounts raise several important theoretical questions concerning the very nature of similarity, with, for example, the sensory, affective, or cognitive underpinnings of similarity judgements remaining unclear. We attempt to shed light on these questions by examining the various accounts of crossmodal associations that have been put forward in the literature. Our suggestion is that perceptual similarity varies from being phenomenologically-based to conceptually-based. In particular, we propose that the nature of the associations underlying similarity judgements – whether these associations are phenomenologically-, structurally-, emotionally-, or conceptually-based – may be represented in a two-dimensional space with associative strength on one axis, and cognitive penetrability on the other.

Cognitive complexity explains processing asymmetry in judgments of similarity versus difference

Cognitive Style Modulates Conscious but Not Unconscious Thought: Comparing the Deliberation-Without-attention Effect in Analytics and Wholists.

Psychological Distance Asymmetry: the Spatial Dimension Vs. Other Dimensions

The Difference Between Differences: How Expertise Affects Diagnosticity of Attribute Alignability

Visual Complexity of Shapes: a Hierarchical Perceptual Learning Model

The role of perceptual similarities in determining the asymmetric mixed-category advantage.

Is subjective perceptual similarity metacognitive?

Ordinal Characterization of Similarity Judgments

Cultural Differences in Visual Search for Geometric Figures

Decoding intelligence via symmetry and asymmetry

Further Support for the Motivational Explanation of Self-Other Similarity Judgment Asymmetry

Similarity As Threat: A Motivational Explanation of Self-Other Similarity Judgment Asymmetry

Matched or moved? Asymmetry in high- and low-level visual processing of motion events

Memory Asymmetry of Forward and Backward Associations in Recognition Tasks

Perceptual Similarity: Insights From Crossmodal Correspondences

Closely matched comparisons suggest that separable processes mediate contextual size illusions

Are they like us or are we like them? Applying the principle of contrast modeling to social identity

Hemispheric Differences in Global/Local Processing Revealed by Same-Different Judgements

Search asymmetries: parallel processing of uncertain sensory information

Circles are like Ellipses, or Ellipses are like Circles? Measuring the Degree of Asymmetry of Static and Contextual Embeddings and the Implications to Representation Learning

Tradeoffs and Comparison Complexity