Abstract:Abstract Understanding how humans perceive the likability of high-dimensional “objects” such as faces is an important problem in both cognitive science and AI/ML. Existing models of human preferences generally assume these preferences to be fixed. However, human assessment of facial attractiveness have been found to be highly context-dependent. Specifically, the classical Beauty-in-Averageness (BiA) effect, whereby a face blended from two original faces is judged to be more attractive than the originals, is significantly diminished or reversed when the original faces are recognizable, or when the morph is mixed-race/mixed gender and the attractiveness judgment is preceded by a race/gender categorization. This effect, dubbed Ugliness-in-Averageness (UiA), has previously been attributed to a disfluency account, which is both qualitative and clumsy in explaining BiA. We hypothesize, instead, that these contextual influences on face processing result from the dependence of attractiveness perception on an element of statistical typicality, and from an attentional mechanism that restricts face representation to a task-relevant subset of features, thus redefining typicality within that subspace. Furthermore, we propose a principled explanation of why statistically atypical objects are less likable: they incur greater encoding or processing cost associated with a greater prediction error, when the brain uses predictive coding to compare the actual stimulus properties with those expected from its associated categorical prototype. We use simulations to show our model provides a parsimonious, statistically grounded, and quantitative account of contextual dependence of attractiveness. We also validate our model using experimental data from a gender categorization task. Finally, we make model predictions for a proposed experiment that can disambiguate the previous disfluency account and our statistical typicality theory.

Revealing the Beauty behind the Sleeping Beauty Problem

The Sleeping Beauty Problem -- A Real-World Solution

Revisiting the Sleeping Beauty problem

The end of Sleeping Beauty's nightmare

Stunned by Sleeping Beauty: How Prince Probability updates his forecast upon their fateful encounter

A Bayesian Approach to Forward and Inverse Abstract Argumentation Problems

A Bayesian Approach to Direct and Inverse Abstract Argumentation Problems

Resolving Bertrand's Probability Paradox

Dormitory of Physical and Engineering Sciences: Sleeping Beauties May Be Sleeping Innovations Part 1: Basic Properties, Cognitive Environment, Characteristics of the Princes

Distinguishing Sleeping Beauties in Science

Beauty-in-averageness and its contextual modulations: A Bayesian statistical account

Inference for Multiple and Conditional Observers

Thomas Bayes's Bayesian Inference

Puzzles of Anthropic Reasoning Resolved Using Full Non-indexical Conditioning

Inconsistency and Acausality in Bayesian Inference for Physical Problems

Learning from conditional probabilities

On the relevance of the Bayesian approach to Statistics

Holes in Bayesian Statistics

Practical Bayesian Inference in Neuroscience: Or How I Learned To Stop Worrying and Embrace the Distribution

Bayesian inference for psychology. Part I: Theoretical advantages and practical ramifications

A Bayesian approach for the analysis of error rate studies in forensic science