Martin T. Barlow
Abstract:We consider models for inference which involve observers which may have multiple copies, such as in the Sleeping Beauty problem. We establish a framework for describing these problems on a probability space satisfying Kolmogorov's axioms, and this enables the main competing solutions to be compared precisely.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the reasoning problem when the existence and multiplicity of observers in a random experiment are affected by the experimental results. Specifically, the author aims to establish a probability space framework that satisfies Kolmogorov's axioms to describe models involving multiple-copy observers (such as the "Sleeping Beauty problem"). Through this framework, the main competing solutions can be accurately compared.
### Core problems of the paper
1. **Existence and multiplicity of observers**: In some physical and philosophical problems, the existence and number of observers may be affected by the results of random experiments. For example, in cosmology, only the universe within a specific range of parameters can support complex chemical reactions and, in turn, support the existence of observers.
2. **Conditional observers**: The existence of these observers depends on the experimental results, such as Sleeping Beauty (SB) in the "Sleeping Beauty problem", who is awakened multiple times in an isolated room but does not know the previous situation each time she wakes up.
3. **Probabilistic reasoning**: When the existence and multiplicity of observers are affected by the experimental results, how to conduct probabilistic reasoning? In particular, how to define an appropriate probability measure to describe the experiences of these observers?
### Specific problem examples
- **Sleeping Beauty problem**: Sleeping Beauty (SB) is awakened in an experiment, but she does not know the specific result of the experiment (whether the coin is heads or tails). The paper explores the probabilities that she should assign to the coin results in different situations.
### Research objectives
- **Establish a probability framework**: Construct a probability space \(\Omega=\Omega_O\times\Omega_A\), where \(\Omega_O\) describes the "possible worlds" and \(\Omega_A\) describes the position of the observer in the world.
- **Define a reasonable probability measure**: Propose and verify some principles (such as the empty - set principle, the principle of indifference, and the principle of equivalent information) to determine the appropriate Anthropic Observer (AO) probability measure \(P_A\).
### Main conclusions
- **Uniqueness**: Under the given principles, there is a unique Anthropic probability measure \(P_E\) that satisfies the principle of indifference (PI) and the principle of equivalent information (PEI).
- **Application**: In the standard "Sleeping Beauty problem", \(P_E(\text{Heads})=\frac{1}{3}\), while the Halfer measure \(P_L(\text{Heads}) = \frac{1}{2}\) based on Lewis's principal principle.
### Summary
This paper solves the probabilistic reasoning problem involving conditional observers by introducing an extended probability space and reasonable principles, and provides a clear answer to the "Sleeping Beauty problem". This not only helps to understand complex probabilistic reasoning problems but also provides a theoretical basis for similar problems.