Abstract:The synthesis of the polycrystalline niobium silicate catalyst AM-11 was first reported in 1998 [1], but its structure proved to be elusive. In 2007 we received two samples from the Aveiro group. At the time, we were looking for a material suitable for the application of the texture method of structure solution, and AM-11 seemed to be ideal for this purpose. One of the samples had needle and the other platelet morphology, and textured samples could be prepared in both cases. The conventional powder diffraction pattern could be indexed on a hexagonal, an orthorhombic or a monoclinic unit cell, so this was the first issue to be resolved. The texture measurements quickly revealed that the crystal system was orthorhombic, but the structure resisted solution. We then tried applying the precession electron diffraction technique in combination with high-resolution powder diffraction data, but beyond confirming the orthorhombic symmetry, these data did not help us to solve the structure. Another attempt was made with a new sample and an improved texture setup, but to no avail. Rotation electron diffraction data and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy images showed that some disorder was present and helped to define the space group, but the structure remained a mystery. The powder charge-flipping routine in Superflip [2], yielded tantalizingly clear electron density maps, but they could not be interpreted sensibly. The unit cell parameters were seen to be related to those of the titanium silicate zorite [3] (one axis doubled in AM-11), so the problem was taken up once again last year. By starting with a simplified zorite framework structure with Nb in place of Ti, and performing what amounts to manual Fourier recycling, the surprisingly simple structure (1Nb, 3 Si, 9 O), which is significantly different from zorite, finally revealed itself. There is some stacking disorder, but the structure is otherwise innocuous. What made it so difficult to solve?

Comment on "Twin symmetry texture of energetically condensed niobium thin films on sapphire substrates (a-plane Al2O3)" [J. Appl. Phys. 110, 033523 (2011)]

Comments on structural and electrical analysis of polycrystalline ceramic PbCaBiNbO6 by A.K. Panda et al. ]

Crystalline Anisotropy of Β-Ga2o3 Thin Films on a C-Plane GaN Template and a Sapphire Substrate

Large thermal anisotropy in monoclinic niobium trisulfide: a thermal expansion tensor study

Unveiling Interface Structure and Polarity of Wurtzite ZnO Film Epitaxially Grown on A-Plane Sapphire Substrate

Comments on the errors in paper "Impact of KBiTiO3 in optical and ferroelectric behavior of NaNbO3 solid solution" by S.K. Mohanty et al., and published in J. Mater. Sci.: Mater. Electron. 34 (2023) 2126

Unusual tilted growth and epitaxial relationship of NaCl B1-structured NiO and CrN on r-plane Al2O3

Comment on the paper "Multiferroic and optical spectroscopic behavior of BST in BFO environment" by B. Mohanty et al.

High-resolution x-ray scattering from epitaxial thin films of Y/Nb on Al2O3

Why Was the Structure of the Niobium Silicate Am-11 So Difficult to Solve?

Equiatomic CoCrFeNi Thin Films on C‐Sapphire: The Role of Twins and Orientation Relationships

Coexistence Of Epitaxial Lattice Rotation And Twinning Tilt Induced By Surface Symmetry Mismatch

Formation mechanism of (10-13) AlN twins on m-plane sapphire substrates at high temperature by hydride vapor phase epitaxy

The lattice distortion of β-Ga2O3 film grown on c-plane sapphire

Growth windows of epitaxial $\textrm{Nb}_x\textrm{N}$ films on c-plane sapphire and their structural and superconducting properties

Effect of substrate microstructure on the misorientation of a -plane ZnO film investigated using x-ray diffraction

Rotational Reconstruction of Sapphire (0001)

Twinning Structures in Near-Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate Single Crystals

Interface structure of (130) twin in the U-14.0 at.% Nb alloy: an experimental and theoretical study

Structural Analysis of Mo Thin Films on Sapphire Substrates for Epitaxial Growth of AlN

Microstructural Analysis of Heteroepitaxial Β-Ga2o3 Films Grown on (0001) Sapphire by Halide Vapor Phase Epitaxy