Abstract:Audit committee systems are presumed to be an effective corporate governance mechanism. There is much empirical evidence based on Chinese capital market data to support the conclusion that audit committee systems have improved the quality of accounting information. On the other hand, some theoretical papers describe fundamental problems within the environment of audit committees, such as system design and legal system aspects. Our research aims to further investigate the relationship between firms, audit committees and earnings quality, represented by the value relevance of earnings. Based on capital market data from 2002 to 2004, we investigate the effectiveness of audit committee mechanisms from the viewpoint of improving earning quality. Our main findings are: (1) based on cross-sectional data, the firms with audit committees show higher earnings quality. However, this higher earnings quality also existed before the setting up of the audit committee when compared to firms that choose not to set up an audit committee; (2) after controlling for the pre-setup difference in earnings quality, no difference is found in earnings quality between the firms with and without audit committees. Our findings do not suggest that audit committees have improved the quality of accounting information.Our results have an important implication for further research about the effectiveness of the audit committee system. We find that firms with higher earnings quality tend to set up audit committees. Researchers who hope to evaluate the effectiveness of audit committees should control for this self-selection effect. And more importantly, future research should test the effectiveness of audit committee systems from viewpoints other than earnings quality.

The Audit Committee's IT Expertise and Its Impact on the Disclosure of Cybersecurity Risk

The Impact of Audit Committee Information Technology Expertise on the Reliability and Timeliness of Financial Reporting

Can board IT expertise improve corporate internal control?

Does Audit Committee Accounting Expertise Help to Promote Audit Quality? Evidence from Auditor Reporting of Internal Control Weaknesses

The hidden cost of silence: How delayed cyberattack disclosure erodes firm profitability

Information Technology Capability, Internal Control Effectiveness, and Audit Fees and Delays

Audit Committee Independence and Financial Expertise and Earnings Management: Evidence from China

The Association between Information Technology Investments and Audit Risk

Audit committee-auditor interlocking and disclosure of key audit matters

The Relationship between Board-Level Technology Committees and Reported Security Breaches

Empirical Research on the Influence of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee to Audit Opinions

The Impact of Audit Committee Financial Expertise on Management Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) Tone

Audit committee quality, auditor independence, and internal control weaknesses

Clients’ digitalization, audit firms’ digital expertise, and audit quality: evidence from China

The Impact of Artificial Intelligence and Cyber Security on Audit Quality

Audit Committee Mechanisms and the Improvement of Earnings Quality

The Role of Internal Control Disclosure in Financial Reporting Precision and the Quality of Audited Financial Reports

The Audit Implications of Cloud Computing

Spillover Effects of Internal Control Weakness Disclosures: the Role of Audit Committees and Board Connections

Certification of Audit Committee Effectiveness: Evidence from a One-Time Regulatory Event in China

Cai, Charlie X. and Hillier, David and Tian, Gaoliang and Wu, Qinghua (2015) Do audit committees reduce the agency costs of ownership