Abstract:In this paper, we present a new method of establishing the fundamental motion equations of nonholonomic systems without using any variational principles. According to the invariance of motion equations under the generalized coordinates transformation and the nonholonomic constraint function groups transformation, the double index tensor analysis method is proposed cooperating with the product rules of matrix. Then we let first integrals equivalent to the corresponding nonholonomic constraints imposed upon the system to explain the self consistency of nonholonomic systems, it is shown that the self consistency is the core of nonholonomic mechanics and can verify which model is appropriate for describing nonholonomic systems. Therefore, the form of nonholonomic constraint force is determined only by three qualities: the invariance of the motion equations under the constraint of first integrals, the invariance of nonholonomic constraint force under the generalized coordinates transformation and the nonholonomic constraint function groups transformation, to establish the fundamental motion equation of nonholonomic systems. Using the double index tensor analysis method, the three qualities and the Moore-Penrose generalized inverse of matrix theory, the equation of motion of nonholonomic systems are derived. Some classical equations in nonholonomic systems, such as the Routh equation, the Nielsen equation and the Chaplygin equation are also derived to prove our method. The method is totally based on the self consistency of nonholonomic systems and the covariation of motion equations, these two characters are naturally derived from mathematical and mechanical requirements of nonholonomic systems. Not only does not use any transcendental variational principles, such as D'Alembert-Lagrange principle, Gauss principle or Jourdian principle, but also illustrate that the validity of the three principles are attributed to the two characters. Further more, this method even provides a reasonable explanation for Chetaev conditions in nonholonomic systems, and shows that the vakonomic mechanics derived by Hamilton's principle is not an appropriate model for nonholonomic systems.

On non-holonomic systems and variational principles

Equations of motion for general nonholonomic systems from the d'Alembert principle via an algebraic method

A New Method for Establishing Motion Equations in Nonholonomic Systems

Action principles for dissipative, non-holonomic Newtonian mechanics

Differential variational principles & equations of mechanical systems with unilateral constraints

Dynamics of Nonholonomic Systems from Variational Principles Embedded Variation Identity

A Variational Principle for Contact Hamiltonian Systems

A Unifying Action Principle for Classical Mechanical Systems

On nonholonomic and vakonomic dynamics of mechanical systems with nonintegrable constraints

A Generalization of Chetaev's Principle for a Class of Higher Order Non-holonomic Constraints

The principles of Lagrange–d'Alembert and Hamilton applied to a rigid bar subject to nonholonomic constraints

A dialectical view of the variational principles of mechanics

Differential Equations of Motion for Constrained Systems with Respect to Three Kinds of Nonholonomic Variations

The origin of variational principles

Unconventional Hamilton-type Variational Principles for Analytical Mechanics

Trends in ferromagnetism, hole localization, and acceptor level depth for Mn substitution in

Nonholonomic reduction for mechanical systems with collisions

Routh Equation of Nonholonomic Dynamical Systems: from Chetaev Condition to Euler Condition

On Two Fundamental Statements of Mechanics

Nonholonomic mechanics and virtual constraints on Riemannian homogeneous spaces