Color transparency: 33 years and still running

Mark Strikman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812796950_0008

2008-01-08

Abstract:I review history of the color transparency (CT) which started with discovery of the $J/\psi$ meson, discovery of high energy CT phenomena and the recent progress in the investigations of CT at intermediate energies.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Color Transparency: past, present and future

D. Dutta,K. Hafidi,M. Strikman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ppnp.2012.11.001

2012-11-13

Abstract:We review a unique prediction of Quantum Chromo Dynamics, called color transparency (CT), where the final (and/or initial) state interactions of hadrons with the nuclear medium must vanish for exclusive processes at high momentum transfers. We retrace the progress of our understanding of this phenomenon, which began with the discovery of the $J/\psi$ meson, followed by the discovery of high energy CT phenomena, the recent developments in the investigations of the onset of CT at intermediate energies and the directions for future studies.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Experiment
In Search for (QUANTUM) Color Transparency

Boris Kopeliovich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9305286

1993-05-19

Abstract:Color transparency (CT) is an effect of suppression of nuclear shadowing of hard reactions, closely related to the color screening. A brief review of theoretical development and experimental search for CT, failed and successful, are presented. A special emphasis is made on a quantum-mechanical nature of CT, as opposed to a wide spread erroneousclassical treatment of this phenomenon. The typical predictions of the classical approach, all contradicting quantum mechanics are: - factorization of cross section of hard reactions on a nucleus;\\ - "nuclear transparency", a normalized ratio of nuclear to nucleon cross sections, cannot exceed one;\\ - the larger is a radius of a hadron, the stronger it attenuates in a nucleus;\\ - the higher is the energy of hadrons participating in a hard reaction, the less is the nuclear attenuation;\\ - due to CT hard processes provide a better opportunity to study Fermi-momentum distribution, than soft reactions; etc. (Talk presented at XXVIII Rencontres de Moriond, March 1993)

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Color transparency of $K^+$ meson produced in the inclusive $(e,e^\prime)$ reaction on nuclei

Swapan Das

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.100.035203

2019-10-30

Abstract:Color transparency is studied for the $K^+$ meson produced due to large four-momentum transfer in the $(e,e^\prime)$ reaction on nuclei. The variation of the $K^+$ meson color transparency ($K^+$CT) with the photon virtuality, and kaon momentum is investigated. The calculated results for $K^+$CT are compared with the data reported from Jefferson Laboratory.

Nuclear Theory,Nuclear Experiment
Color Transparency and the Proton Form Factor- Feynman Wins

Olivia Caplow-Munro,Gerald A. Miller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.104.L012201

2021-04-23

Abstract:A recent experiment [{\bf Phys. Rev. Lett. 126,082301 (2021)}] used the $(e,e'p)$ reaction on $^{12}$C to search for the effects of color transparency (the absence of final state interactions). Color transparency was said to be ruled out. The ability to observe the effects of color transparency depends on the ability of a putative point-like-configuration (PLC), formed in a high-momentum transfer coherent reaction, to escape the nucleus without expanding its size. We study the expansion aspect of color transparency using superconformal baryon-meson symmetry and light-front holographic QCD. A new formalism is obtained and used to analyze the recent experiment. The resulting conclusion is that effects of expansion would not be sufficiently significant in causing final state interactions to occur. Therefore we conclude that a PLC was not formed. This means that the Feynman mechanism involving virtual photon absorption on a single high momentum quark is responsible for high momentum electromagnetic form factor of the proton.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Experiment
Constraints on the onset of color transparency from quasi-elastic $^{12}$C$(e,e'p)$ up to $Q^2=\,14.2\,$(GeV$/c)^2$

D. Bhetuwal,J. Matter,H. Szumila-Vance,C. Ayerbe Gayoso,M. L. Kabir,D. Dutta,R. Ent,D. Abrams,Z. Ahmed,B. Aljawrneh,S. Alsalmi,R.Ambrose,D. Androic,W. Armstrong,A. Asaturyan,K. Assumin-Gyimah,A. Bandari,S. Basnet,V. Berdnikov,H. Bhatt,D. Biswas,W. U. Boeglin,P. Bosted,E. Brash,M. H. S. Bukhari,H. Chen,J.P. Chen,M. Chen,E. M. Christy,S. Covrig,K. Craycraft,S. Danagoulian,D. Day,M. Diefenthaler,M. Dlamini,J. Dunne,B. Duran,R. Evans,H. Fenker,N. Fomin,E. Fuchey,D. Gaskell,T. N. Gautam,F. A. Gonzalez,J. O. Hansen,F. Hauenstein,A. V. Hernandez,T. Horn,G. M. Huber,M. K. Jones,S. Joosten,A. Karki,C. Keppel,A. Khanal,P. M. King,E. Kinney,H. S. Ko,M. Kohl,N. Lashley-Colthirst,S. Li,W. B. Li,A. H. Liyanage,D. Mack,S. Malace,P. Markowitz,D. Meekins,R. Michaels,A. Mkrtchyan,H. Mkrtchyan,S.J. Nazeer,S. Nanda,G. Niculescu,I. Niculescu,D. Nguyen,Nuruzzaman,B.Pandey,S.Park,E.Pooser,A. Puckett,M. Rehfuss,J. Reinhold,N. Santiesteban,B. Sawatzky,G. R. Smith,A. Sun,V.Tadevosyan,R.Trotta,S. A.Wood,C.Yero,J. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.108.025203

2023-08-15

Abstract:Quasi-elastic scattering on $^{12}$C$(e,e'p)$ was measured in Hall C at Jefferson Lab for space-like 4-momentum transfer squared $Q^2$ in the range of 8--14.2\,(GeV/$c$)$^2$ with proton momenta up to 8.3\,GeV/$c$. The experiment was carried out in the upgraded Hall C at Jefferson Lab. It used the existing high momentum spectrometer and the new super high momentum spectrometer to detect the scattered electrons and protons in coincidence. The nuclear transparency was extracted as the ratio of the measured yield to the yield calculated in the plane wave impulse approximation. Additionally, the transparency of the $1s_{1/2}$ and $1p_{3/2}$ shell protons in $^{12}$C was extracted, and the asymmetry of the missing momentum distribution was examined for hints of the quantum chromodynamics prediction of Color Transparency. All of these results were found to be consistent with traditional nuclear physics and inconsistent with the onset of Color Transparency.

Nuclear Experiment
Physics observables for color transparency

Bernard Pire

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9712264

1997-12-04

Abstract:The physics observables dedicated to the study of color transparency are diverse. After a brief pedagogical introduction, we emphasize the complementarity of the nuclear filtering and color transparency concepts. The importance of quantum interferences leads to suspect pictures based on the preparation of a squeezed state of small transverse size leading to a rapid transverse expansion. The different roles of heavy and light nuclei are emphasized. The possibility of color transparency tests in the vacuum is stressed. Such a test may be quickly addressed in the virtual Compton scattering reactions at CEBAF or HERMES energies.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Quantum Color Transparency and Nuclear Filtering

Pankaj Jain,Bernard Pire,John P. Ralston

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0370-1573%2895%2900071-2

1995-11-16

Abstract:Color transparency is the proposal that under certain circumstances the strong interactions can be reduced in magnitude. We give a comprehensive review of the physics, which hinges on the interface of perturbative QCD with non--perturbative strong interactions. Color transparency is complementary to {\it nuclear filtering}, which is the conversion of quark wave functions in hadrons to small transverse space dimensions by interaction with a nuclear medium. We review current approaches, including pictures based on modeling the time evolution of hadronic wave--packets as well as the use of light cone matrix elements. Spin plays an intrinsic role in testing and understanding the physics and is discussed at length. We emphasize the use of data analysis procedures which have minimal model dependence. We also review existing experimental data and the experimental program planned at various facilities. The subject has strong scientific complementarity and potential to make progress in exploring hadron physics at current and future facilities.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Theory
Coherent Nuclear Difractive Production of Mini-Jets - Signature of Color Transparency

G.A. Miller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.nucl-th/9908039

1999-08-12

Abstract:The process $\pi + A$ leading to a pair of mini-jets at high relative transverse momentum ($k_t \gsim 2$ GeV) while leaving the nucleus in its ground state was selected as a definitive test of the existence of color transparency by Frankfurt, Miller and Strikman in 1993. The preliminary results of Fermilab experiment E791, led by Ashery and Weiss-Babai, show a strong A-dependence, consistent with the notion of color transparency.

Nuclear Theory
The Geometrical Color Optics Of Coherent High Energy Processes

L.L.Frankfurt,G.A. Miller,M. Strikman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.ns.44.120194.002441

1994-07-12

Abstract:CONTENTS. <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://1.Introduction" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>, 1.1 QCD ideas to be tested; 2. Coherence phenomena in QED, 2.1 Charge transparency, 2.2 Charge filtering, 2.3 Charge opacity; 3. Color transparency in perturbative QCD, 3.1 Coherence length in QCD, 3.2 Bjorken scaling for deep inelastic processes, 3.3 Hard Coherent Diffraction {}From Nucleons and Nuclei; 4. Soft Diffractive Physics and Color Fluctuations, 4.1 Scattering eigenstates formalism; 4.2 Current information on color fluctuations in Hadrons, 4.3 Small Size Configurations in Pions, 4.4 Nuclear inelastic diffraction as evidence for color fluctuations near the average value, 4.5 Inelastic screening corrections to the total cross sections; 5. Color transparency in nuclear quasielastic reactions. 5.1 Is a small system made?, 5.2 Time development, 5.3 Relevant data; 6. Color fluctuations in nucleons and nucleus-nucleus collisions, 6.1 Color opacity effects, 6.2 Color fluctuations and central collisions, 6.3 Leading hadron transparency effects in central collisions.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Theory
Study of Color Transparency in Production of Vector Mesons off Nuclei

J. Nemchik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A%3A1023492310246

2002-11-15

Abstract:Within a light-cone QCD formalism based on the Green function technique incorporating color transparency, coherence length effects and gluon shadowing we study electroproduction of vector mesons off nuclei. We found rather large color transparency effects in the range of Q^2 < 10-20 GeV^2. They are stronger at low than at high energies and can be easily identified by HERMES or at JLab. We provide predictions for incoherent and coherent vector meson production for future measurements.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Color transparency in hard $pd$ collisions

A.B. Larionov

2024-09-12

Abstract:As one of the predictions of perturbative QCD, the effect of color transparency has been the focus of attention in the community studying modifications of hadrons in nuclear medium for several decades. The search for this effect in reactions involving heavy nuclei can be complicated by uncertainties in nuclear characteristics (nucleon density distributions and wave functions), which can affect the interpretation of experiments. In this work, we consider the reaction $d(p,pp)n$ at $p_{\rm lab}=15$ GeV/c caused by hard elastic $pp$ scattering, in which these uncertainties are actually reduced to the behavior of the deuteron wave function at large momenta. It is shown that for transverse momenta of the spectator neutron $\leq 0.4$ GeV/c the choice of the deuteron wave function cannot affect the identification of the color transparency effect. A simple method for studying color transparency in $dd$ collisions is also suggested based on the identification of quasi-free $pd$ interactions.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Physics - Experiment,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Experiment
Proposal to PAC 51: Color Transparency in Maximal Rescattering Kinematics

Shujie Li,Carlos Yero,Jennifer Rittenhouse West,Holly Szumila-Vance,Douglas W. Higinbotham

2023-12-06

Abstract:With the current highest beam energy at Jefferson Lab and traditional methods, we have exhausted our sensitivity for observing the onset of proton color transparency in a nucleus in A(e,e'p) parallel scattering kinematics for up to $Q^{2}$ = 14 GeV$^{2}$ . One of the disadvantages in A(e,e'p) experiments is that even if a point-like color singlet is produced at such $Q^{2}$, its expansion is unconstrained over the full radius of the nuclei, with the potential to significantly reduce the size of the color transparency effect. Therefore, in order to be sensitive to the effects of color transparency, we enhance the sensitivity of the measurement to the production of a point-like color neutral object prior to the onset of wave-function expansion. In this experiment, we propose a color transparency measurement in maximal rescattering ("dirty") kinematics in deuterium where final-state interactions (FSIs) are known to be huge effects, thereby enhancing our sensitivity to a reduction in FSIs indicative of color transparency. The kinematics in exclusive processes in deuterium can be precisely chosen such that the inter-nucleon distances of the struck and spectator nucleon lead to well-controlled FSIs.

Nuclear Experiment
Color Transparency and Saturation in QCD

Dieter Schildknecht

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1210.0733

2012-10-02

Abstract:We review the theoretical interpretation of deep-inelastic electron-proton scattering at low values of the Bjorken variable $x \simeq Q^2/W^2 \lsim 0.1$. The process proceeds via the interaction of quark-antiquark $(q \bar q)$ color-dipole fluctuations of the (virtual) photon with the proton. In terms of the forward Compton scattering amplitude, two reaction channels contribute to the interaction of the $q \bar q$ color dipole with the gluon field in the proton. Dependent on the kinematics, there is either {\it color transparency}, corresponding to a cancellation of the amplitudes for the two reaction channels, or {\it saturation}, occuring when the process is dominated by a single interaction channel. The connection between the color-dipole picture and the pQCD improved parton model is elaborated upon.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Ruling out color transparency in quasi-elastic $^{12}$C(e,e'p) up to $Q^2$ of 14.2 (GeV/c)$^2$

D. Bhetuwal,J. Matter,H. Szumila-Vance,M. L. Kabir,D. Dutta,R. Ent,D. Abrams,Z. Ahmed,B. Aljawrneh,S. Alsalmi,R. Ambrose,D. Androic,W. Armstrong,A. Asaturyan,K. Assumin-Gyimah,C. Ayerbe Gayoso,A. Bandari,S. Basnet,V. Berdnikov,H. Bhatt,D. Biswas,W. U. Boeglin,P. Bosted,E. Brash,M. H. S. Bukhari,H. Chen,J. P. Chen,M. Chen,E. M. Christy,S. Covrig,K. Craycraft,S. Danagoulian,D. Day,M. Diefenthaler,M. Dlamini,J. Dunne,B. Duran,R. Evans,H. Fenker,N. Fomin,E. Fuchey,D. Gaskell,T. N. Gautam,F. A. Gonzalez,J. O. Hansen,F. Hauenstein,A. V. Hernandez,T. Horn,G. M. Huber,M. K. Jones,S. Joosten,A. Karki,C. Keppel,A. Khanal,P. M. King,E. Kinney,H. S. Ko,M. Kohl,N. Lashley-Colthirst,S. Li,W. B. Li,A. H. Liyanage,D. Mack,S. Malace,P. Markowitz,D. Meekins,R. Michaels,A. Mkrtchyan,H. Mkrtchyan,S. J. Nazeer,S. Nanda,G. Niculescu,I. Niculescu,D. Nguyen,Nuruzzaman,B. Pandey,S. Park,E. Pooser,A. Puckett,M. Rehfuss,J. Reinhold,N. Santiesteban,B. Sawatzky,G. R. Smith,A. Sun,V. Tadevosyan,R. Trotta,S. A. Wood,C. Yero,J. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.126.082301

2021-03-02

Abstract:Quasielastic $^{12}$C$(e,e'p)$ scattering was measured at space-like 4-momentum transfer squared $Q^2$~=~8, 9.4, 11.4, and 14.2 (GeV/c)$^2$, the highest ever achieved to date. Nuclear transparency for this reaction was extracted by comparing the measured yield to that expected from a plane-wave impulse approximation calculation without any final state interactions. The measured transparency was consistent with no $Q^2$ dependence, up to proton momenta of 8.5~GeV/c, ruling out the quantum chromodynamics effect of color transparency at the measured $Q^2$ scales in exclusive $(e,e'p)$ reactions. These results impose strict constraints on models of color transparency for protons.

Nuclear Experiment,High Energy Physics - Experiment,Nuclear Theory
Color Transparency and Light Front Holographic QCD

Gerald A. Miller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.02019

2022-03-04

Abstract:Color transparency, the reduction of initial- or final-state interactions in coherent nuclear processes, is a natural prediction of QCD provided that small-sized or point-like configurations (PLCs) are responsible for high-momentum transfer, high-energy, semi-exclusive processes. I use the FMS criteria for the existence of PLCs to show that the wave functions of light front holographic QCD, as currently formulated, do not contain a PLC.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Nuclear Experiment,Nuclear Theory
Asymmetry of the Missing Momentum Distribution in (e,e$'$p) Reactions and Color Trnasparency

A. Bianconi,S. Boffi,D.E. Kharzeev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693%2894%2990013-2

1993-10-30

Abstract:We suggest the measurement of the integrated asymmetry of teh missing momentum distribution in (e,e$'$p)reactions to check color transparency effects at intermediate momentum transfers.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Color, from baryon spectroscopy to qcd

O.W. Greenberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9301207

1993-01-05

Abstract:I review the discovery of the color degree of freedom in hadronic physics, and the developments which led from that discovery to the local gauge theory of color, quantum chromodynamics.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Novel color center platforms enabling fundamental scientific discovery

Victoria Norman,Sridhar Majety,Zhipan Wang,William H. Casey,Nicholas Curro,Marina Radulaski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/inf2.12128

2020-04-30

Abstract:Color centers are versatile systems that generate quantum light, sense magnetic fields and produce spin-photon entanglement. We review how these properties have pushed the limits of fundamental knowledge in a variety of scientific disciplines, from rejecting local-realistic theories to sensing superconducting phase transitions. In the light of recent progress in material processing and device fabrication, we identify new opportunities for interdisciplinary fundamental discoveries in physics and geochemistry.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Optics,Quantum Physics
Technicolor 2000

Kenneth Lane

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/0007304

2000-07-27

Abstract:This review is based on lectures on technicolor and extended technicolor presented at the Frascati Spring School in May 2000. I summarize the motivation and structure of this theory of dynamical breaking of electroweak and flavor symmetries. Particular attention is paid to the main phenomenological obstacles to this picture-flavor-changing neutral currents, precision electroweak measurements, and the large top-quark mass-and their proposed resolutions-walking technicolor and topcolor-assisted technicolor. I then discuss the signatures for technicolor and the existing and upcoming searches for them at LEP, the Tevatron Collider, and the Large Hadron Collider. The final section lists some outstanding theoretical questions.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment
Nuclear Production of Charmonium at ELFE Energies

S. Gardner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.nucl-th/9512006

1995-12-04

Nuclear Theory

Abstract:I discuss the diffractive production of charmonium from nuclei and the anomalous nuclear attenuation --- termed ``color transparency'' --- attributed to such processes, focusing on the few tens of GeV energy regime germane to the ELFE project. A critical review of color transparency calculations is presented, and the major sources of uncertainty are emphasized.

Color transparency: 33 years and still running

Color Transparency: past, present and future

In Search for (QUANTUM) Color Transparency

Color transparency of $K^+$ meson produced in the inclusive $(e,e^\prime)$ reaction on nuclei

Color Transparency and the Proton Form Factor- Feynman Wins

Constraints on the onset of color transparency from quasi-elastic $^{12}$C$(e,e'p)$ up to $Q^2=\,14.2\,$(GeV$/c)^2$

Physics observables for color transparency

Quantum Color Transparency and Nuclear Filtering

Coherent Nuclear Difractive Production of Mini-Jets - Signature of Color Transparency

The Geometrical Color Optics Of Coherent High Energy Processes

Study of Color Transparency in Production of Vector Mesons off Nuclei

Color transparency in hard $pd$ collisions

Proposal to PAC 51: Color Transparency in Maximal Rescattering Kinematics

Color Transparency and Saturation in QCD

Ruling out color transparency in quasi-elastic $^{12}$C(e,e'p) up to $Q^2$ of 14.2 (GeV/c)$^2$

Color Transparency and Light Front Holographic QCD

Asymmetry of the Missing Momentum Distribution in (e,e$'$p) Reactions and Color Trnasparency

Color, from baryon spectroscopy to qcd

Novel color center platforms enabling fundamental scientific discovery

Technicolor 2000

Nuclear Production of Charmonium at ELFE Energies