Estimation of Centrifugal Pump Efficiency at Variable Frequency for Irrigation Systems

Dorin Bordeasu,Florin Dragan,Ioan Filip,Iosif Szeidert,Gelu Ovidiu Tirian
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16104134
IF: 3.9
2024-05-16
Sustainability
Abstract:The sustainability of the food production achieved with the help of irrigation systems and the sustainability of their energy consumption are major challenges of the current century. Pumping systems currently account for approximately 30% of global electrical energy consumption. As electricity prices rise, there is a growing need for technological advancements to enhance energy efficiency and reduce consumption costs effectively. This study focuses on operating centrifugal pumps at variable frequency as an effective means of achieving this goal. Most centrifugal pump manufacturers/providers traditionally assume that pump efficiency remains constant across various operating frequencies, often equating the efficiency at various frequencies to that at the standard frequency (50/60 Hz). In contrast, this paper introduces a new formula for estimating pump efficiency, crucial to precise power consumption determination, particularly in variable-frequency scenarios. The formula parameters are identified by using experimental data acquired from an existing pumping system. The tests and results presented in this paper demonstrate that the proposed formula outperforms the formulas of the current industry standards in accuracy. Practically, the new relation assures enhanced accuracy in estimating pump efficiency and absorbed power, allowing for the design of a more precise model used for control systems synthesis required for operating centrifugal pumps at variable frequency. This research offers a new way of calculating pump efficiency, which could be very useful for industry practitioners seeking to optimize energy consumption in pumping systems.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper mainly addresses the following issues: ### Research Background and Objectives - **Background**: With the growth of the global population, climate change, and the intensification of the energy crisis, the sustainable development of irrigation systems and their energy consumption efficiency have become major challenges of the 21st century. Currently, pumping systems account for approximately 30% of global electricity consumption, and as one of the important water use systems, irrigation systems have significant implications for energy sustainability. - **Objectives**: This paper proposes a new efficiency estimation formula for centrifugal pumps operating under variable frequency. Traditionally, centrifugal pump manufacturers usually assume that the efficiency of the pump remains constant at different frequencies. However, this paper proposes a new formula based on experimental data to more accurately estimate the pump's efficiency and power consumption, especially in variable frequency scenarios. ### Main Contributions - **New Formula**: By applying system identification techniques to experimental data from actual pumping systems, a new efficiency estimation formula is proposed. The parameters of this formula are determined based on experimental data, and compared to existing industry standard formulas, it can more accurately estimate the efficiency of centrifugal pumps. - **Validation and Comparison**: The paper validates the proposed formula through experimental data and compares it with existing methods (manufacturer-provided methods, Anderson formula, and Sârbu formula). The results show that the new formula significantly outperforms other methods in terms of accuracy, which is crucial for optimizing the energy consumption of pumping systems. ### Conclusion - The new formula proposed in this paper can more accurately estimate the efficiency and absorbed power of centrifugal pumps operating under variable frequency, aiding in the design of more precise control structures for the operation of pumping systems. This is not only very useful for industrial practitioners but also helps improve the overall energy efficiency of pumping systems. In summary, this study aims to enhance the energy utilization efficiency of centrifugal pumps operating in variable frequency modes by introducing a new efficiency estimation method, thereby promoting the sustainable development of irrigation systems and the entire pumping industry.