Comment on ``Conduction states in oxide perovskites: Three manifestations of Ti$^{3 +}$ Jahn-Teller polarons in barium titanate''

S. A. Prosandeev,I. P. Raevski,M. A. Bunin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.70.157101

2003-04-08

Abstract:In this comment to [S. Lenjer, O. F. Schirmer, H. Hesse, and Th. W. Kool, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 66}, 165106 (2002)] we discuss the electronic structure of oxygen vacancies in perovskites. First principles computations are in favour of rather deep levels in these vacancies, and Lenjer et al suggest that the electrons' interaction energy is negative, but data on electroconductivity are against.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the interaction between oxygen vacancies (V_O) and titanium ions (Ti³⁺) in barium titanate (BaTiO₃) and their influence on electrical conductivity and electronic structure. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following key issues:

1. **Contradiction between experimental and theoretical calculations**:
- Experimentally, Scharfschwerdt et al. observed a signal in reduced BaTiO₃ by EPR spectroscopy, which they attributed to Ti³⁺ ions (V_O²⁺Ti³⁺) bound to double - charged oxygen vacancies (V_O²⁺).
- Theoretical studies, however, suggest that the F - center - like state of single - charged oxygen vacancies (V_O⁺) may have lower energy, but no EPR signal of this state was found in the experiment.

2. **Charge state of oxygen vacancies and its influence on electrical conductivity**:
- The charge state of oxygen vacancies under different degrees of reduction has a significant impact on their electrical conductivity. Highly reduced samples are usually black and have a high n - type electrical conductivity, while samples with low reduction are transparent and have low electrical conductivity.
- Electrical conductivity data indicate that oxygen vacancies can be in three different charge states: no electron, one electron, or two electrons. Among them, the state with two electrons has a lower activation energy, while the single - charged oxygen vacancy (V_O⁺) has a higher activation energy.

3. **Electronic structure and energy level of oxygen vacancies**:
- Theoretical calculations predict that the electronic energy level of single - charged oxygen vacancies (V_O⁺) is about 0.6 eV, which is higher than the top of the valence band (i.e., 2.7 eV below the bottom of the conduction band), which is in contradiction to the high electrical conductivity and black phenomenon observed in highly reduced samples.
- It is necessary to explain why highly reduced samples show high electrical conductivity and black color while the electronic activation energy of oxygen vacancies is high.

4. **Controversy over the negative - U - center hypothesis**:
- Lenjer et al. proposed that oxygen vacancies are negative - U centers to explain the non - observation of the EPR signal of single - charged oxygen vacancies in the experiment. However, this hypothesis is inconsistent with the results of theoretical calculations, which consider oxygen vacancies as positive - U centers.

5. **Necessity for further research**:
- The paper points out that more experimental and theoretical research is needed to explain the electronic structure of oxygen vacancies and their behavior under different degrees of reduction, especially to explain the experimentally observed activation energy by first - principles calculations.

In summary, this paper aims to explore and solve the complexity of the interaction between oxygen vacancies and titanium ions in barium titanate, especially the changes in electrical conductivity and electronic structure under different degrees of reduction, and attempts to reconcile the contradiction between experiment and theory.