Reply to "Comment on 'Anisotropic Scattering Caused by Apical Oxygen Vacancies in Thin Films of Overdoped High Temperature Cuprate Superconductors'"

Da Wang,Jun-Qi Xu,Hai-Jun Zhang,Qiang-Hua Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2207.02503

2022-07-06

Abstract:In our recent work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 137001 (2002)], we proposed that the apical oxygen vacancies act as anisotropic scattering impurities. Within the Born approximation, this leads to a quasi-particle scattering rate that is maximal (zero) in the antinodal (nodal) direction. This unique angular dependence provides a straightforward mechanism for some puzzling experimental results in overdoped La$_{2-x}$Sr$_x$CuO$_4$ (LSCO) films regarding the superfluid density $\rho_s$ and optical conductivity $\sigma_1$. In a recent comment by H. U. Ozdemir et al. [<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2206.01301" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.01301">arXiv:2206.01301</a>], the importance of the nature of the impurity scattering is re-emphasized, but some challenges to our picture are raised: that we did not consider the change of the electrostatic potential for in-plane electrons once the apical oxygen is missing, the change of Fermi surface topology as the van Hove point is passed, self-energy corrections caused by d-wave pairing, and vertex corrections caused by forward scattering. These concerns are interesting but are either irrelevant or further enhances our conclusions. We discuss these points one by one in this reply.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to respond to the comments of Ozdemir et al. on previous research. In the original research, the authors proposed the concept of apical oxygen vacancies as anisotropic scattering impurities. Through the Born approximation, this scattering leads to the quasiparticle scattering rate being maximum in the antinodal direction and minimum in the nodal direction. This unique angular dependence provides a direct mechanism for explaining some puzzling experimental results of the superfluid density \(\rho_s\) and the optical conductivity \(\sigma_1\) in overdoped La\(_{2 - x}\)Sr\(_x\)CuO\(_4\) (LSCO) films.

In their recent comments, Ozdemir et al. raised some challenges, including:
1. Failure to consider the change in the electrostatic potential of in - plane electrons after apical oxygen deficiency.
2. The change in Fermi - surface topology with doping.
3. The self - energy correction caused by d - wave pairing.
4. The vertex correction caused by forward scattering.

In this reply, the authors discuss these challenges one by one, pointing out that:
- The energy scale of the electrostatic potential change is relatively small and is not sufficient to significantly change the effective parameters of the Zhang - Rice singlet, so it has little impact on their conclusions.
- For the overdoped region, the Fermi - surface topology no longer changes, and the normal state can be effectively described by the Landau Fermi - liquid theory, so the change in Fermi - surface topology is irrelevant to their work.
- In overdoped LSCO films, the scattering rate \(\Gamma\) is much larger than the superconducting gap \(\Delta\), approaching the dirty limit, so the self - energy correction caused by d - wave pairing can be ignored.
- In their model, forward scattering does not cause current - vertex correction, so this also does not affect their conclusions.

Overall, the authors believe that these challenges are either insignificant or further strengthen their conclusion that apical oxygen vacancies lead to anisotropic scattering.