Ab Initio Calculation of Impurity Effects in Copper Oxide Materials

L.-L. Wang,P. J. Hirschfeld,H.-P. Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.72.224516

2005-05-01

Abstract:We describe a method for calculating, within density functional theory, the electronic structure associated with typical defects which substitute for Cu in the CuO2 planes of high-Tc superconducting materials. The focus is primarily on Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8, the material on which most STM measurements of impurity resonances in the superconducting state have been performed. The magnitudes of the effective potentials found for Zn, Ni and vacancies on the in-plane Cu sites in this host material are remarkably consistent with phenomenological fits of potential scattering models to STM resonance energies. The effective potential ranges are quite short, of order 1 A with weak long range tails, in contrast to some current models of extended potentials which attempt to fit STM data. For the case of Zn and Cu vacancies, the effective potentials are strongly repulsive, and states on the impurity site near the Fermi level are simply removed. The local density of states (LDOS) just above the impurity is nevertheless found to be a maximum in the case of Zn and a local minimum in case of the vacancy, in agreement with experiment. The Zn and Cu vacancy patterns are explained as due to the long-range tails of the effective impurity potential at the sample surface. The case of Ni is richer due to the Ni atom's strong hybridization with states near the Fermi level; in particular, the short range part of the potential is attractive, and the LDOS is found to vary rapidly with distance from the surface and from the impurity site. We propose that the current controversy surrounding the observed STM patterns can be resolved by properly accounting for the effective impurity potentials and wave-functions near the cuprate surface. Other aspects of the impurity states for all three species are discussed.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the influence of typical defects (such as zinc, nickel and copper vacancies) in cuprate materials, especially Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 (abbreviated as BSCCO), on the electronic structure. Specifically, the research focuses on how these defects affect the local electronic states and the resonant states measured by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) when they substitute copper atoms in the CuO2 plane of high - temperature superconductors.

### Main problems:
1. **Influence of defects on electronic structure**: Calculate and explain the effective potentials of common defects such as Zn, Ni and Cu vacancies in BSCCO and their influence on the electronic states through density functional theory (DFT).
2. **Explanation of STM observations**: Explain the local density of states (LDOS) patterns observed in STM experiments, especially the energy and spatial distribution of resonant states around different defects.
3. **Verification of theoretical models**: Verify whether existing theoretical models (such as the point - like potential scattering model) can explain the experimental results, and propose improvements or new theoretical explanations.

### Research methods:
- **DFT calculations**: Use DFT to calculate the electronic structures of BSCCO surfaces doped with Zn, Ni and Cu vacancies, including total energy, partial density of states (PDOS), effective potentials, etc.
- **STM simulations**: Simulate STM images based on the effective potentials calculated by DFT and compare them with experimental results.
- **Effective potential analysis**: Analyze the effective potentials of different defects in detail, and explore their short - range and long - range characteristics and their influence on STM patterns.

### Key findings:
- **Effective potential characteristics**: The effective potential ranges of Zn, Ni and Cu vacancies are about 1 Å, and they have significant short - range characteristics, which are different from some models assuming extended potentials.
- **Explanation of STM patterns**: The effective potentials obtained by DFT calculations can well explain the STM patterns observed in experiments, especially the spatial distributions near Zn and Cu vacancies.
- **Resonant state energies**: The calculated resonant state energies are highly consistent with the experimental values, which are Zn (1.8 meV), Ni (10.5 meV) and Cu vacancy (0.9 meV) respectively, close to the experimental values (Zn: 1.5 meV, Ni: 9 meV, Cu vacancy: 0.5 meV).

In conclusion, through DFT calculations and theoretical analysis, this paper reveals the effective potentials of different defects in the superconducting state of cuprates and their influence on the electronic structure, providing an important theoretical basis for understanding the impurity effects in high - temperature superconductors.