Abstract:By influencing beliefs about electoral quality, international election observation missions (EOMs) play an important role in shaping post-election contention. As the number and variety of international organizations (IOs) involved in election observation has grown, many elections host multiple missions and disagreement among them is common. This phenomenon of competing judgments is particularly prevalent in electoral authoritarian regimes, as leaders seek to invite 'friendly' IOs to counteract possible criticism from more established EOMs. Drawing from research about the varying domestic credibility of EOMs and the demobilizing effects of disinformation, we argue that compared to unified criticism, competing judgments among EOMs increase uncertainty about electoral quality, which in turn dampens post-election contention. Using newly available data on EOM statements as reported in the international media, we show that competing judgments reduce post-election contention in a sample of 115 countries from 1990–2012. A survey experiment in Turkey solidifies the micro-foundations of our argument: individuals exposed to competing judgments have more positive perceptions of election quality and less support for post-election mobilization, compared to those receiving information only about EOM criticism. Our findings provide systematic evidence that governments holding flawed elections have incentives to invite multiple election observation missions to hedge against the political risks of criticism.

Conflict under the shadow of elections

Elections As a Conflict Processing Mechanism

A model of conflict and leadership: Is there a hawkish drift in politics?

To Act or not to Act? Political competition in the presence of a threat

Persuasion, betrayal and regret in election campaigns

Electoral Campaigns as Dynamic Contests

Arms Spending and War Casualties: Understanding the Strategic Trade-Offs in Warfare

Political Instability and the Failure of Deterrence

Voters and the trade-off between policy stability and responsiveness

Noncooperative dynamics in election interference

Domestic constraints in crisis bargaining

Effectiveness of Incumbent’s Strategic Communication during Economic Crisis under Electoral Authoritarianism: Evidence from Turkey

Persistence in power of long-lived parties

Until the Bitter End? The Diffusion of Surrender Across Battles

Electoral Incentives and Negotiated Settlements: Legislative Deliberation on the Mindanao Conflict in the Philippines

Competing judgments: Multiple election observers and post-election contention

Impact of Information Concerning the Popularity of Candidates on Loss-Averse Voters’ Abstention

External Threats, Political Turnover and Fiscal Capacity

Punching above One's Weight–On Overcommitment in Election Campaigns

Exogenous shocks and electoral outcomes