S.-K. Mo,G.-H. Gweon,J.D. Denlinger,H.-D. Kim,J.W. Allen,C.G. Olson,H. Höchst,J.L. Sarrao,Z. Fisk
Abstract:In contrast to our recent finding of an X-point band gap in divalent hexaborides, we report here that angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) data shows that the gap is absent for trivalent LaB$_6$ and is absent or nearly so for mixed valent SmB$_6$. This finding demonstrates a nontrivial evolution of the band structure from divalent to trivalent hexaborides.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there is an overlap or an energy gap in the band structure of rare earth hexaborides at the X - point. Specifically, the research focuses on comparing the differences in the band structures between divalent and trivalent rare earth hexaborides to reveal the changes in their electronic properties.
### Main problems:
1. **Differences in band structures between divalent and trivalent hexaborides**: The paper aims to explore how the band structure of the material changes when the rare - earth element changes from divalent (such as SrB₆ and EuB₆) to trivalent (such as LaB₆).
2. **Existence or non - existence of the X - point energy gap**: For divalent hexaborides, previous angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) studies have shown that there is an X - point energy gap of about 0.8 eV, which makes these materials exhibit insulator properties. For trivalent hexaborides (such as LaB₆) and mixed - valent hexaborides (such as SmB₆), the paper attempts to confirm whether there is a similar energy gap.
### Research background:
- **Divalent hexaborides**: Previous studies have shown that divalent hexaborides (such as SrB₆ and EuB₆) have a significant energy gap at the X - point, making them exhibit insulator properties.
- **Trivalent hexaborides**: Theoretically, if trivalent hexaborides have no energy gap at the X - point, they should be semi - metallic conductors. However, the experimental results are not clear, so further verification is required.
### Research methods:
- **ARPES experiment**: Through the angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) technique, the researchers measured the electronic band structures of LaB₆ and SmB₆ and compared them with the theoretical calculation results.
- **XAS and XES experiments**: To further confirm the existence of the energy gap, the researchers also used supplementary experimental means such as X - ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and X - ray emission spectroscopy (XES).
### Main findings:
- For trivalent LaB₆, the experimental results show that there is almost no energy gap at the X - point, and there is an overlap between the bands.
- For the mixed - valent SmB₆, the energy gap is very small or almost non - existent, and the bands may have a slight contact or there may be a small energy gap (about 0.1 eV) at the X - point.
### Conclusion:
This research reveals that the band structure of rare earth hexaborides changes significantly with the change in the valence state of the rare - earth element. Specifically, the transition from divalent to trivalent leads to a transition in the band structure from insulator to semi - metallic conductor, which provides important experimental evidence for understanding the electronic properties of these materials.
### Formula representation:
The energy gap size involved in the paper can be represented by the following formulas:
\[ E_g = 0.8 \, \text{eV} \quad (\text{for divalent hexaborides}) \]
\[ E_g \approx 0 \, \text{eV} \quad (\text{for trivalent LaB₆}) \]
\[ E_g \leq 0.1 \, \text{eV} \quad (\text{for mixed - valent SmB₆}) \]
These results indicate that with the change in the valence state of the rare - earth element, the band structure of hexaborides has undergone a non - trivial evolution.