Henry P. Stapp
Abstract:It is shown how environmental decoherence plays an essential and constructive role in a quantum mechanical theory of brain process that has significant explanatory power.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the role of quantum decoherence in brain processes and its impact on the connection between consciousness and the brain. Specifically, the author Henry P. Stapp aims to show how environmental decoherence plays an important role in brain processes within the theoretical framework of quantum mechanics, and this role is positive rather than destructive.
### Background of the Paper
1. **Max Tegmark's Research**: Tegmark estimated that the time required for environmental interactions to destroy macroscopic quantum coherence in the brain is only \(10^{-23}\) seconds. This extremely short time seems to rule out the important role of macroscopic quantum effects in understanding the connection between brain processes and conscious thinking, thus questioning Penrose's theory of consciousness.
2. **Stapp's Theory**: Stapp proposed a detailed theory of the brain - consciousness connection, which assumes that environmental decoherence has a significant impact on brain processes. His theory is designed in such a way that those specific quantum effects that allow an individual's thoughts to influence their brain are not affected by environmental decoherence. This enables the theory to explain non - trivial conditions of human behavior under controlled situations, and these conditions have been verified by empirical psychological data in the past five decades.
### Main Contributions
1. **Macroscopic Quantum Effects**: Stapp's theory emphasizes that the macroscopic quantum effects in the brain are different from those used in quantum computing. The latter are quickly destroyed by environmental decoherence, while the former can function in the presence of environmental decoherence.
2. **Quantum Mechanics Framework**: Stapp's theory is based on the quantum mechanics framework of John von Neumann and Eugene Wigner, which regards human conscious experience as fundamental reality and describes the entire physical universe, including the human brain and body, through mathematical formulas.
3. **Influence of Consciousness on the Brain**: Stapp's theory explains how macroscopic quantum effects can produce a direct influence of consciousness on the brain in the presence of a large amount of environmental decoherence. This influence can explain detailed empirical facts, such as the role of attention and willpower.
### Key Mechanisms
1. **Mixing of Quantum States**: Environmental decoherence causes the brain state \(S(t)_b\) to rapidly evolve into a mixture of classical states. However, this mixed state does not mean a single classical state, but the co - existence of multiple possible states.
2. **Quantum Zeno Effect**: Through will - effort, people can control brain activity by rapidly repeating quantum processes (as shown in formula (3)) to prevent it from "wandering". This effect is similar to the quantum Zeno effect, that is, frequent measurements can suppress transitions between states.
3. **Projection Operators**: Each conscious experience \(E\) is associated with a projection operator \(P(E)\) that acts on the brain state \(S(t)_b\), eliminating all activity patterns that are incompatible with that experience. For example, if the experience \(E\) is updating the world representation, then \(P(E)\) will retain those brain activity patterns that contribute to memory update.
### Explanatory Power
1. **Psychological Support**: Stapp cited the view in William James' "A Primer of Psychology" that James believed that the essence of willpower is to maintain attention on an object through effort. This is consistent with the influence of consciousness on brain processes in Stapp's quantum theory.
2. **Empirical Research**: Stapp also cited the empirical research in William Pashler's "The Psychology of Attention", which supports his theory, especially regarding the processes of parallel processing and selection bottlenecks.
In conclusion, this paper, by combining the perspectives of quantum mechanics and psychology, proposes a new theory that can explain the influence of consciousness on the brain, challenges traditional views, and provides new directions for future research.