Abstract:ABSTRACT The severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 pandemic has raised public awareness about the importance of hygiene, leading to an increased demand for antimicrobial surfaces to minimize microbial contamination on high-touch surfaces. This is particularly relevant in public and private transportation settings, where surfaces frequently touched by individuals pose a significant, yet preventable, risk of infection transmission. Typically, the antimicrobial activity of surfaces is tested using test methods of the International Standards Organization, American Society for Testing and Materials, or Japanese Industrial Standards, which involve complete submersion in liquid, elevated temperature (37°C), and prolonged (24 h) contact periods. However, these conditions do not accurately represent real-world scenarios where surfaces are exposed to air. In this study, we propose a modified test method designed to better reflect real-life conditions in the intended end-use setting. The modifications included using deionized water instead of nutrient broth while preparing bacterial inoculum, applying a small test inoculum to the surface and allowing it to dry, maintaining ambient temperature and relative humidity throughout the contact period, and reducing the contact period to 4 h. With this modified approach, the antimicrobial activity of 20 samples was reassessed. This screening revealed that out of 20 samples, only 2 samples were effective against all species, while 8 samples demonstrated partial effectiveness against selected species, and 10 samples showed no significant effect. These findings highlight the inadequacy of the current test standard and emphasize the urgent necessity for revised and adapted testing method to ensure a reliable and accurate evaluation. IMPORTANCE The recent severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 pandemic has sparked increased demand for antimicrobial surfaces to mitigate the risk of fomites-transmitted infection in both indoors and confined spaces. Commonly, the antimicrobial activity of these surfaces is assessed using test standards established by national standards bodies, which do not distinguish between different application scenarios. While these test standards are suitable for surfaces intended for submerged application, they are inappropriate for antimicrobial surfaces designed for dry surface exposure. The usage of these standards can lead to an overestimation of antimicrobial efficacy. Thus, this study introduces a modified dry exposure test method aimed at better reflecting real-life conditions in the intended end-use setting. Our results revealed the subpar antimicrobial performance of numerous samples, highlighting the necessity to revise and tailor the universal test standard to real-world scenarios in order to ensure a reliable and accurate evaluation.

Development of a Test Method for Analyzing the Hygienic Performance of Commercial Dishwashers Operating on the Fresh Water Principle

Hygiene in Commercial Dishwashing – A Review about the State of Knowledge in Research, Standardization, Regulation and Market Information

STUDY ON WASHING METHOD OF MEDICAL APPARATUS AND INSTRUMENT

Preliminary Results for a New Final Package Test to Assess the Quality of Sterile Package Systems

[Determination of the detergent efficiency of the detergents disinfecting for surfaces]

A new approach to testing the efficacy of drinking water disinfectants

Microbiological and chemical analyses of stainless steel and ceramics subjected to repeated soiling and cleaning treatments

Reduce and refine: Plasma treated water vs conventional disinfectants for conveyor-belt cleaning in sustainable food-production lines

A realistic approach for evaluating antimicrobial surfaces for dry surface exposure scenarios

Developing and testing a new quantitative near infrared spectroscopy online tracking measuring system for soil detection during automatic dishwashing

Simulations of thermal phase changes and bacterial inactivation in a superheated steam dishwasher

Achieving hygiene in the domestic kitchen: the effectiveness of commonly used cleaning procedures

Performance of the AOAC use-dilution method with targeted modifications: collaborative study

With a Little Help from My Friends: The Role of Detergents for Energy, Efficiency, and Hygiene in Domestic Dishwashing

Microbial diversity of dishwashers in different cities of China in spring, summer, autumn and winter

A standardized method for evaluating test soils used to demonstrate cleaning efficacy

Cultivation-Based Quantification and Identification of Bacteria at Two Hygienic Key Sides of Domestic Washing Machines

Optimization of temperature for effective cleaning with a novel cleaning rig: Influence of soil and surface types

Design and Performance of Systems for Cleaning Product-Contact Surfaces of Food Equipment: A Review

How Do We Determine the Efficacy of an Antibacterial Surface? A Review of Standardised Antibacterial Material Testing Methods

Study on microbial diversity of washing machines