Yueyi Tan,Jusheng Song,Lei Yu,Yunxi Bai,Jianfeng Zhang,Man-Ha (Sylvia) Chan,Jeroen van van Ameijde
Abstract:In old urban districts with tenement buildings, street markets address the working class's social and economic needs. They are pivotal in fostering supportive communities, in particular for low-income residents in sub-standard housing. However, their outdated overall environment impedes the delivery of adequate support to residents. Prior research on street markets has focused on those in the Americas and Europe, and has revealed the societal support values of these markets. However, studies on street markets in high-density cities like Hong Kong are lacking. This study introduces an evaluation framework to assess the impact of street markets on the development of supportive communities for Hong Kong's sub-divided apartment residents. Employing the Pei Ho Street market in Sham Shui Po as a case study, an importance-performance analysis highlights critical but underperforming factors including public facilities, activity venues, commerce, and employment. Based on these findings, the study proposes four improvement strategies for the renewal of street markets in high-density communities, which could apply to other cities with similar high-density urban environments. It concludes that street markets in Hong Kong display unique spatial characteristics shaped by low-income lifestyles in a high-density urban environment, enriching daily social life and promoting sustainable community development.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to explore how the markets in the old urban areas of Hong Kong promote the formation of supportive communities. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects:
1. **The value of markets in high - density urban environments**: Although past research has mainly focused on markets in the Americas and Europe, relatively little research has been done on markets in high - density cities like Hong Kong. Therefore, this paper attempts to fill this research gap and explore the unique spatial characteristics of markets in the old urban areas of Hong Kong and their enriching role in social life.
2. **The influence mechanism of markets on supportive communities**: The research attempts to reveal how markets promote the formation of supportive communities by providing public facilities, activity venues, business opportunities, and employment opportunities. These functions are especially important for low - income residents living in subdivided units.
3. **Identification of key influencing factors and improvement strategies**: Through field observations, literature reviews, and structured interviews, the research proposes a framework for evaluating the impact of markets and identifies key factors that need urgent improvement through Importance - Performance Analysis (IPA). Based on these findings, the research proposes four improvement strategies to enhance the role of markets in high - density communities.
### Research background
The old urban areas in Hong Kong, such as Sham Shui Po and Yau Tsim Mong districts, are the core areas of urban sustainable development, providing rich shopping, dining, entertainment, and cultural experiences. However, with the development of the city, these areas face many challenges, such as insufficient public health, lack of community facilities, poor living environments, and over - population. In particular, the low - income groups living in subdivided units are the groups that need supportive community services the most.
### Research methods
1. **Proposing an evaluation framework**: Through field observations, literature reviews, and structured interviews, propose a framework for evaluating the impact of markets on supportive communities.
2. **Social surveys**: Including site selection observations and Importance - Performance Analysis questionnaires to obtain the social attributes of residents in subdivided units and their importance and performance scores for market evaluation factors.
3. **Data analysis**: Identify the influencing factors of markets through paired - sample t - tests and conduct Importance - Performance Analysis to find out those factors with high importance but low performance.
4. **Proposing improvement suggestions**: Based on the results of Importance - Performance Analysis, further analyze the influencing factors that need urgent improvement and propose specific improvement suggestions.
### Conclusion
The research found that markets in Hong Kong have unique spatial characteristics in high - density urban environments, which can enrich daily social life and promote sustainable community development. By improving public facilities, activity venues, business opportunities, and employment opportunities, the role of markets in the construction of supportive communities can be significantly enhanced. These findings are not only applicable to Hong Kong but can also provide references for other high - density cities.