Exploring Non-Linear and Synergistic Effects of Street Environment on the Spirit of Place in Historic Districts: Using Multi-Source Data and XGBoost

Shuxiao Ma,Wei Huang,Nana Cui,Zhaoyang Cai,Yan Xu,Yue Qiao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16125182
IF: 3.9
2024-06-19
Sustainability
Abstract:The fragmented remodeling of historic districts undermines the spirit of place. Understanding the intricate relationship between the neighborhood environment and the spirit of place is essential for sustainable urban development. Current research predominantly relies on case studies and the concept of place, which are subjective and lack specific analysis of how the neighborhood environment shapes the spirit of place. In this study, we examine Chuancheng Street in Handan City as a case study. Utilizing the eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) model and multi-source data, combined with SHapley Additive exPlanation (SHAP) and Partial Dependence Plots (PDP), we analyze the non-linear and synergistic effects of the street environment on the spirit of place in historic districts. The findings reveal that (1) the proportion of enduring sociability (PES) on the street significantly shapes the spirit of place, with cultural space elements being less prioritized in perception; (2) PES, green vision index (GVI), Integration_800 m, and mixed land use (MLU) have pronounced non-linear impacts on the spirit of place, with strong threshold effects, and these factors also demonstrate a synergistic effect; (3) There are notable spatial variations in the spirit of place across different blocks, particularly influenced by the authenticity of cultural heritage. This study provides fundamental insights into the spirit of place in historic neighborhoods, enabling a better understanding of complex urban dynamics and informing future street regeneration from a place perspective.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: understanding the complex relationship between the neighborhood environment and the "genius loci" of historical neighborhoods, especially the non - linear and synergetic effects. Specifically: 1. **How to quantify and evaluate the influence of the street environment in historical neighborhoods on the "genius loci"**: The research analyzed the non - linear and synergetic effects of these factors on the "genius loci" by using multi - source data (such as road networks, points of interest (POI), street - view images, etc.) and the XGBoost model, combined with SHapley Additive exPlanation (SHAP) and Partial Dependence Plots (PDP). 2. **How to measure residents' perception of the "genius loci" in historical neighborhoods**: The research proposed an index system containing four indicators (behavior categories, convenience, urban culture, spatial characteristics) to evaluate the "genius loci" in historical neighborhoods. 3. **The influence of different administrative regions on the perception of the "genius loci"**: The research explored the spatial differences in the perception of the "genius loci" in different neighborhoods, with particular attention to the influence of the authenticity of cultural heritage on this perception. ### Key Findings - **The Proportion of Enduring Sociality (PES) has a significant impact on the "genius loci"**: The research found that the proportion of enduring social activities on the street is crucial for the formation of the "genius loci", while cultural space elements are less prioritized in perception. - **Significant non - linear and synergetic effects**: Factors such as PES, Green View Index (GVI), Integration within 800m (Integration_800m) and Mixed Land Use (MLU) have significant non - linear effects on the "genius loci", and there are synergetic effects among these factors. - **Obvious spatial differences**: There are significant spatial differences in the perception of the "genius loci" in different neighborhoods, especially in areas greatly influenced by the authenticity of cultural heritage. ### Method Overview - **Data collection**: Use platforms such as Baidu Maps and Amap to obtain multi - source data such as road networks, POI, and street - view images. - **Model construction**: Adopt the XGBoost model combined with SHAP and PDP techniques to analyze non - linear and synergetic effects. - **Index system**: Construct a comprehensive index system including physical space elements, cultural space elements and human behavior elements. Through these methods, the research provides important insights for understanding the "genius loci" in historical neighborhoods, which is helpful for future neighborhood regeneration and cultural regeneration work.