Martijn W. Ketelaars,Peter Borm
Abstract:We analyze clearing mechanisms in financial networks in which agents may have both monetary individual assets and mutual liabilities. A clearing mechanism prescribes mutual payments between agents in a financial network to settle their mutual liabilities. The corresponding payments, summarized in a payment matrix, are made in accordance with agent-specific claims rules that stem from the vast literature on claims situations. The bottom payment matrix is the payment matrix that contains the minimal amount of payments required to clear the network. We explicitly characterize the bottom payment matrix as the result of a recursive centralized mechanism. We subsequently show that several types of decentralized clearing mechanisms lead to the bottom payment matrix as well. In fact, we show that this unification of centralized and decentralized clearing mechanisms relies on the composition property of the underlying agent-specific claims rules that dictate the payment mechanism.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the unification of clearing mechanisms in financial networks, particularly between centralized and decentralized clearing mechanisms. Specifically, the paper analyzes how, in a financial network, when agents (such as banks or financial institutions) may have individual assets and mutual liabilities, a clearing mechanism can be used to specify mutual payments between agents to settle their mutual debts. These payments are aggregated in a payment matrix, following agent-specific claim rules derived from extensive literature on claim situations.
### Core Issues of the Paper
1. **Definition and Role of Clearing Mechanisms**: The paper first defines a clearing mechanism, which is used in financial networks to settle mutual debts by specifying mutual payments between agents.
2. **Minimum Payment Matrix**: The paper clearly describes the minimum payment matrix (i.e., the bottom payment matrix), which is the least amount of payment required to clear the network.
3. **Unification of Centralized and Decentralized Clearing Mechanisms**: The paper demonstrates that several types of decentralized clearing mechanisms can also lead to the bottom payment matrix, and this unification relies on the combinatorial properties of the underlying agent-specific claim rules.
### Key Contributions
- **Recursive Centralized Mechanism for the Bottom Payment Matrix**: The paper explicitly characterizes the bottom payment matrix through a recursive centralized mechanism.
- **Effectiveness of Decentralized Clearing Mechanisms**: The paper proves that several types of decentralized clearing mechanisms, under certain conditions (such as combinatorial properties), can also generate the bottom payment matrix.
- **Importance of Combinatorial Properties**: The paper emphasizes the key role of combinatorial properties in unifying centralized and decentralized clearing mechanisms.
### Application Background
- **Financial Contagion**: The research background of the paper includes the phenomenon of financial contagion, where exogenous or endogenous shocks may lead to the collapse of the financial system, causing defaults by other agents or systems.
- **Bankruptcy Situations**: The paper also discusses bankruptcy situations in network settings, particularly highlighting the importance of studying bankruptcy situations during the global financial crisis and the recent COVID-19 pandemic.
### Methods and Results
- **Mathematical Methods**: The paper uses mathematical methods, particularly fixed-point theory and the monotone convergence theorem, to prove the unification of centralized and decentralized clearing mechanisms.
- **Recursive Process**: The paper proposes a recursive process to construct the bottom payment matrix and proves the convergence of this process.
- **Variants of Decentralized Clearing Mechanisms**: The paper also introduces a variant of decentralized clearing mechanisms based on the Individual Settlement Allocation Procedure (ISAP) and proves that it can also generate the bottom payment matrix.
In summary, through mathematical methods and a recursive process, this paper successfully unifies centralized and decentralized clearing mechanisms, providing new perspectives and solutions to the clearing problem in financial networks.