Abstract:Structural variants (SVs) are one of the significant types of DNA mutations and are typically defined as larger-than-50-bp genomic alterations that include insertions, deletions, duplications, inversions, and translocations. These modifications can profoundly impact the phenotypic characteristics and contribute to disorders like cancer, response to treatment, and infections. Four long-read aligners and five SV callers have been evaluated using three Oxford Nanopore NGS human genome datasets in terms of precision, recall, and F1-score statistical metrics, depth of coverage, and speed of analysis. The best SV caller regarding recall, precision, and F1-score when matched with different aligners at different coverage levels tend to vary depending on the dataset and the specific SV types being analyzed. However, based on our findings, Sniffles and CuteSV tend to perform well across different aligners and coverage levels, followed by SVIM, PBSV, and SVDSS in the last place. The CuteSV caller has the highest average F1-score (82.51%) and recall (78.50%), and Sniffles has the highest average precision value (94.33%). Minimap2 as an aligner and Sniffles as an SV caller act as a strong base for the pipeline of SV calling because of their high speed and reasonable accomplishment. PBSV has a lower average F1-score, precision, and recall and may generate more false positives and overlook some actual SVs. Our results are valuable in the comprehensive evaluation of popular SV callers and aligners as they provide insight into the performance of several long-read aligners and SV callers and serve as a reference for researchers in selecting the most suitable tools for SV detection.

Long-read-based human genomic structural variation detection with cuteSV

SVDF: enhancing structural variation detect from long-read sequencing via automatic filtering strategies

SVvalidation: A long-read-based validation method for genomic structural variation

Comprehensive Evaluation of Structural Variant Genotyping Methods Based on Long-Read Sequencing Data.

Comprehensive and deep evaluation of structural variation detection pipelines with third-generation sequencing data

Tradeoffs in alignment and assembly-based methods for structural variant detection with long-read sequencing data

FocalSV: target region-based structural variant assembly and refinement using single-molecule long read sequencing data

A graph clustering algorithm for detection and genotyping of structural variants from long reads

Benchmarking long-read aligners and SV callers for structural variation detection in Oxford nanopore sequencing data

SVision: a deep learning approach to resolve complex structural variants

Long-read sequencing and structural variant characterization in 1,019 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project

De novo and somatic structural variant discovery with SVision-pro

A Practical Guide for Structural Variation Detection in the Human Genome

SvABA: genome-wide detection of structural variants and indels by local assembly

PGG.SV: a whole-genome-sequencing-based structural variant resource and data analysis platform

Sharpen SV detection

CSV-Filter: a deep learning-based comprehensive structural variant filtering method for both short and long reads

SVmine Improves Structural Variation Detection by Integrative Mining of Predictions from Multiple Algorithms

Long-range somatic structural variation calling from matched tumor-normal co-assembly graphs

Overview of structural variation calling: Simulation, identification, and visualization

Ingap-Sv: a Novel Scheme to Identify and Visualize Structural Variation from Paired End Mapping Data