Abstract:Better structural variation (SV) detection could improve cancer diagnosis, treatment and prevention. Yet many cancer genomics studies have only reliably detected single nucleotide variants and small indels due to technological limitations of short-read sequencing. While structural variants can be inferred from discordant short read pairs, as much as 70% of SVs remain undetected because of the mappability difficulties. This is especially true for SVs in regions where GC content is greater than 45% or regions which harbor tandem repeats and segmental duplications. Advances in long-read sequencing enabled direct observation of SVs with recall and precision over 95% across a larger portion of the genome. To harness this technology, we developed Severus - a long-read SV caller that provides phased detection of both simple germline SVs as well as complex rearrangements commonly found in cancer genomes. Such rearrangements are built into a breakpoint graph to reconstruct derived tumor chromosome structure. To benchmark Severus and other long-read SV calling methods, we sequenced six tumor/normal cell line pairs using Nanopore, HiFi, short-read and Hi-C sequencing technologies. We combined the calls from multiple tools and technologies to generate benchmarking sets of somatic SV for each tumor cell line, and evaluated short- and long-read tools against this benchmark set. Current tools for SV merging and comparison (such as truvari) were primarily designed for long indels, rather than breakends that are more common in somatic SVs. Another challenge is that different tools may represent the same variants differently in a VCF output. To enable robust somatic SV outputs comparison, we developed a tool called Minda that translates an input VCF entries into a unified representation, and then compares the calls in either pairwise or multi-tool mode. As expected, in our benchmarking of cell six tumor cell line pairs, short-read methods had substantially lower recall and precision, compared to long-read methods. Among the long-read methods, Severus consistently had substantially better recall and precision, compared to Sniffles2, nanomonsv and SAVANA. An analysis of publicly available long-read sequencing of a melanoma cell line (for which curated benchmark SV set is available) produced consistent results. Citation Format: Ayse Keskus, Asher Bryant, Tanveer Ahmad, Ataberk Donmez, Isabel Rodriguez, Nicole Rossi, Yi Xie, Byunggil Yoo, Rose Milano, Hong Lou, Jimin Park, Joshua Gardner, Brandy McNulty, Karen Miga, Mike Dean, Midhat Farooqi, Benedict Paten, Mikhail Kolmogorov. Benchmarking long- and short-read somatic structural variation callers using a multi-technology panel of six tumor/normal cell lines [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2024; Part 1 (Regular s); 2024 Apr 5-10; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2024;84(6_Suppl) nr 2338.

Long-range somatic structural variation calling from matched tumor-normal co-assembly graphs

Abstract 2338: Benchmarking long- and short-read somatic structural variation callers using a multi-technology panel of six tumor/normal cell lines

FocalSV: target region-based structural variant assembly and refinement using single-molecule long read sequencing data

SVcnn: an Accurate Deep Learning-Based Method for Detecting Structural Variation Based on Long-Read Data

Severus: accurate detection and characterization of somatic structural variation in tumor genomes using long reads

The benefit of a complete reference genome for cancer structural variant analysis

SVision-pro: comparative sequence-to-image representation and instance segmentation for de novo and somatic structural variant discovery

Structural variant analysis of a cancer reference cell line sample using multiple sequencing technologies

Structural variation and fusion detection using targeted sequencing data from circulating cell free DNA

Integrative detection and analysis of structural variation in cancer genomes

SVsearcher: A More Accurate Structural Variation Detection Method in Long Read Data.

SAAS-CNV: A Joint Segmentation Approach on Aggregated and Allele Specific Signals for the Identification of Somatic Copy Number Alterations with Next-Generation Sequencing Data.

Tradeoffs in alignment and assembly-based methods for structural variant detection with long-read sequencing data

A graph clustering algorithm for detection and genotyping of structural variants from long reads

SVision: a deep learning approach to resolve complex structural variants

HiSV: A control-free method for structural variation detection from Hi-C data

Identification of Somatic Structural Variants in Solid Tumors by Optical Genome Mapping

Abstract 6257: Genome wide, high-throughput, high-resolution structural variation detection at low variant allele fraction for oncology samples

Evaluating Structural Variation Detection Tools for Long-Read Sequencing Datasets in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

De novo and somatic structural variant discovery with SVision-pro

SvABA: genome-wide detection of structural variants and indels by local assembly