Abstract:The negative effects of nutrient pollution in streams, rivers, and downstream waterbodies remain widespread global problems. Understanding the cost-effectiveness of different strategies for mitigating nutrient pollution is critical to making informed decisions and defining expectations that best utilize limited resources, which is a research priority for the US Environmental Protection Agency. To this end, we modeled nutrient management practices including residue management, cover crops, filter strips, grassed waterways, constructed wetlands, and reducing fertilizer in the upper East Fork of the Little Miami River, an 892 km2 watershed in southwestern Ohio, United States. The watershed is 64% agriculture with 422 km2 of row crops contributing an estimated 71% of the system's nutrient load. The six practices were modeled to treat row crop area, and among them, constructed wetlands ranked highest for their low costs per kilogram of nutrient removed. To meet a 42% phosphorus (P) reduction target for row crops, the model results suggested that the runoff from 85.5% of the row crop area would need to be treated by the equivalent of 3.61 km2 of constructed wetlands at an estimated cost of US$2.4 million annually (or US$48.5 million over a 20-year life cycle). This prompted a series of projects designed to understand the feasibility (defined in terms of build, treatment, and cost potential) of retrofitting the system with the necessary extent of constructed wetlands. The practicalities of building this wetland coverage into the system, while leading to innovation in unit-level design, has highlighted the difficulty of achieving the nutrient reduction target with wetlands alone. Approximately US$1.2 million have been spent on constructing 0.032 km2 of wetlands thus far and a feasibility analysis suggests a cost of US$38 million for an additional 0.409 km2. However, the combined expenditures would only achieve an estimated 13% of the required treatment. The results highlight the potential effectiveness of innovative design strategies for nutrient reduction and the importance of considering realistic field-scale build opportunities, which include accounting for acceptance among landowners, in watershed-scale nutrient reduction simulations using constructed wetlands.

Quantifying the cost-effectiveness of nutrient-removal strategies for a lowland rural watershed: Insights from process-based modeling

Coupling Watershed Environmental Model with Optimizing Method to Provide Least Cost Alternatives in Environmental Planning and Management

Predicting The Impact Of Management Practices On River Water Quality Using Swat In An Agricultural Watershed

An Inversed Bayesian Modeling Approach for Estimating Nitrogen Export Coefficients and Uncertainty Assessment in an Agricultural Watershed in Eastern China

Optimizing Non-Point Source Pollution Management: Evaluating Cost-Effective Strategies in a Small Watershed within the Three Gorges Reservoir Area, China

Implementing constructed wetlands for nutrient reduction at watershed scale: Opportunity to link models and real-world execution

Economic And Environmental Effects Of Nutrient Budgeting Strategies In Animal Excreta Treatment A Case Study From Rural China

A coupled model system to optimize the best management practices for nonpoint source pollution control

Controlling non-point-source pollution by rural resource recycling. Nitrogen runoff in Tai Lake valley, China, as an example

Spatially-Distributed Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Framework to Control Phosphorus from Agricultural Diffuse Pollution

Identification method and application of critical load contribution areas based on river retention effect

Towards Efficient Low Impact Development: A Multi-Scale Simulation-Optimization Approach for Nutrient Removal at the Urban Watershed

Source contribution analysis of nutrient pollution in a P-rich watershed: Implications for integrated water quality management

An Integrated Modeling Approach for Identifying Cost-Effective Strategies in Controlling Water Pollution of Urban Watersheds

Modelling to Lower Energy Consumption in a Large WWTP in China While Optimising Nitrogen Removal

Pollution reduction and operating cost analysis of municipal wastewater treatment in China and implication for future wastewater management

Developing nutrient pollution management strategies on a watershed scale under climate change

Strategy for cost-effective BMPs of non-point source pollution in the small agricultural watershed of Poyang Lake: A case study of the Zhuxi River

The Status and Prospect of Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Rural Wastewater Treatment

Assessing nutrient fate from terrestrial to freshwater systems using a semi-distributed model for the Fuxian Lake Basin, China

Inexact Chance-Constrained Linear Programming Model for Optimal Water Pollution Management at the Watershed Scale