Optimizing Non-Point Source Pollution Management: Evaluating Cost-Effective Strategies in a Small Watershed within the Three Gorges Reservoir Area, China

Renfang Chang,Yunqi Wang,Huifang Liu,Zhen Wang,Lei Ma,Jiancong Zhang,Junjie Li,Zhiyi Yan,Yihui Zhang,Danqing Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13060742
IF: 3.905
2024-05-27
Land
Abstract:Non-point source (NPS) pollution poses a significant threat to the water environment, yet controlling it at the watershed scale remains a formidable challenge. Understanding the characteristics and drivers of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) outputs at the watershed scale, along with identifying cost-effective best management practices (BMPs), is crucial for effective pollution control. In this study, we utilized the Wangjiaqiao watershed within the Three Gorges Reservoir Area (TGRA) as a case study to explore the characteristics of N and P load outputs and their dominant drivers by combining the SWAT model and a geographic detector. Based on our analysis of N and P loads within the watershed, we employed the entropy weight method to evaluate the reduction efficiency and cost-effectiveness of 64 BMP scenarios, encompassing seven measures (vegetative filter strips, parallel terraces, 10% fertilizer reduction, 30% fertilizer reduction, residue cover tillage, grass mulching, and returning farmland to forest) and their combinations. Our findings revealed the following: (1) spatial heterogeneity in NPS loads within the watershed, primarily influenced by land use, fertilizer application, and surface runoff, with interactive enhancement effects among driving factors; (2) the differential effectiveness of BMPs at the watershed level, with structural measures, particularly terracing, exhibiting higher efficacy and achieving reduction rates of 28.12% for total nitrogen (TN) and 37.69% for total phosphorus (TP); the combined BMPs showed improved reduction efficiency, but not merely additive; and (3) in terms of cost-effectiveness, 30% fertilizer reduction emerged as the most beneficial among the individual measures. Moreover, a combination of vegetative filter strips, parallel terraces, and 30% fertilizer reduction demonstrated significant improvements in TN and TP reductions (48.05% and 61.95%, respectively), suggesting their widespread applicability. Overall, our study provides insights into developing a cost-effective BMP strategy for the Wangjiaqiao watershed and offers valuable guidance for NPS pollution management in similar small watersheds within the TGRA.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses the issues of Non-Point Source Pollution (NPS) management, especially the cost-effectiveness strategy evaluation within a small watershed in the Three Gorges Reservoir area in China. The study combines the SWAT model and the geographical detector method to analyze the characteristics, driving factors, and interactive effects of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) output, and evaluates the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of six Best Management Practices (BMPs), including vegetation filter strips, terraces, and fertilizer reduction. The study finds that NPS pollution load exhibits spatial heterogeneity within the watershed, mainly influenced by land use, fertilizer application, and surface runoff, and there is an enhanced effect among these driving factors. The effects of BMPs at the watershed level vary, and structural measures such as terraces demonstrate higher efficiency in significantly reducing total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) emissions. The combined use of BMPs can improve emission reduction efficiency but is not simply additive. In cost-effectiveness analysis, a 30% fertilizer reduction measure is found to be the most economically efficient individual measure. Furthermore, the combination strategy of vegetation filter strips, terraces, and 30% fertilizer reduction performs outstandingly in TN and TP reduction, with wide applicability. The research in this paper provides cost-effective BMP strategies for the Wangjiaqiao watershed and valuable guidance for NPS pollution management in similar small watersheds.