Abstract:Coming from the commognitive standpoint, we consider proof-based mathematics as a distinct discourse, the transition to which requires special rules for endorsement and rejection of mathematical statements. In this study, we investigate newcomers' learning of these rules when being taught them explicitly. Our data come from academically motivated high-school students who took a special course in undergraduate mathematics. The course teacher dedicated three academic hours to introducing and explaining selected rules of proof to support students' shift to the new discourse. The homework assignment consisted of typical proof-requiring problems and a scriptwriting task, asking students to compose a dialogue between fictional characters about a proof-related mistake of their choice. We analyzed the differences and similarities between the rules discussed in the classroom and those that students addressed and implemented in their proofs. The analysis showed that while students' solutions to proof-requiring problems required rule implementation, fictitious dialogues opened the space for rule formulation and substantiation. In many cases, the students discussed the rules presented in the classroom, extending, elaborating, and specifying the teacher's formulations. Furthermore, while the students' proofs were mainly consistent with the teacher's expectations, some of their rule formulations were more radical and overgeneralized than expected. These findings suggest that newcomers' communication about the rules of proof may lag behind their capability to implement those rules to prove mathematical statements.

Teaching practices that support revising definition drafts to adhere to mathematical norms

Sociomathematical scaffolding as students engage in revising draft definitions, conjectures, and proofs

Facing and challenging language ideologies towards a more inclusive understanding of language in mathematics education research—the case of sign languages

Word, Definitions and Concepts in Discourses of Mathematics, Teaching and Learning

Designing and enacting instruction that enhances language for mathematics learning: a review of the state of development and research

Examining the Mathematics in Mathematics Teacher Education

A Teacher’s Conception of Definition and Use of Examples When Doing and Teaching Mathematics

Student Sense-Making in Post-Secondary Introductory Proof Courses: An Argument for and Outline of a Methodological Approach

Transforming Perceptions of Proof: A Four-Part Instructional Sequence

Reflective Groupwork for Introductory Proof-Writing Courses

Task design for ways of working: making distinctions in teaching and learning mathematics

Transitioning to proof via writing scripts on the rules of a new discourse

Design Principles That Support Course Design Innovation for Elementary Mathematics Methods Courses

NCTM’s Principles and Standards for Developing Conceptual Understanding in Mathematics

Mathematical Proofs 101: How Proofs Should Be Read, Written, and Taught

Mathematics-for-Teaching: an Ongoing Investigation of the Mathematics that Teachers (Need to) Know

From Collaborative Construction, Through Whole-Class Presentation, to a Posteriori Reflection: Proof Progression in a Topology Classroom

The design of tasks that address applications to teaching secondary mathematics for use in undergraduate mathematics courses

Mathematics discussions by design: creating opportunities for purposeful participation

Restructuring for Mathematical Power: Techniques for Teaching Thinking in Algebra

Developing understanding of mathematical modeling in secondary teacher preparation