Synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction computed tomography (XRDCT): a new tool in cultural heritage and stone conservation for 3D non-destructive probing and phase analysis of inorganic re-treatments

Elena Possenti,Nicoletta Marinoni,Claudia Conti,Marco Realini,Gavin B M Vaughan,Chiara Colombo,Gavin B. M. Vaughan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3an02208k

2024-02-28

The Analyst

Abstract:The issue of preserving carbonatic stones of cultural heritage (CH) restored in the past that have undergone new decay phenomena is strongly emerging and conservation science has not yet found a reliable solution. In this paper, we propose the application of synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction computed tomography (XRDCT) to explore the effects of using inorganic-mineral products (ammonium oxalate; ammonium phosphate) in sequence as a novel, compatible and effective re-treatment approach to consolidate decayed carbonatic stones already treated with inorganic-mineral treatments. High-quality XRDCT datasets were used to qualitatively/quantitatively investigate and 3D localize the complex mixture of crystalline phases formed after the conservation re-treatments within a porous carbonatic stone substrate. The XRDCT reconstruction images and the structural refinements of XRD patterns with the Rietveld methods showed that the phase composition of reaction products, their volume distribution, and weight fraction vary as a function of the treatment sequence and penetration depth. The high potential of XRDCT allows (i) assessment of peculiar trends of each treatment/treatment sequence; (ii) exploration of the reaction steps of the sequential treatments and (iii) demonstration of the consolidating effect of inorganic re-treatments, non-destructively and at the micron scale. Above all, our study (i) provides new analytical tools to support the conservation choices, (ii) showcases new analytical possibilities for XRDCT in conservation science, including in investigations of CH materials and decay processes, and (iii) opens up new perspectives in analytical chemistry and material characterisation for the non-destructive and non-invasive analysis of reactions within heterogeneous polycrystalline systems.

chemistry, analytical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of deterioration in carbonate stone materials in cultural heritage sites after early restoration efforts. Specifically, it proposes the use of synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction computed tomography (XRDCT) to study inorganic mineral products (ammonium oxalate and diammonium hydrogen phosphate) as novel, compatible, and effective retreatment methods to consolidate deteriorated carbonate stone materials that have already been treated with inorganic mineral products.

The main objectives of the paper include:
1. **Evaluating the effects of different treatment sequences**: Using XRDCT technology to qualitatively and quantitatively study and three-dimensionally locate the complex combinations of multiphase mixtures in a porous carbonate matrix.
2. **Exploring reaction steps**: Investigating the reaction steps in the sequential treatment process and demonstrating the consolidation effects of inorganic retreatment, achieving non-destructive micron-level analysis.
3. **Providing new analytical tools**: Offering new analytical tools for conservation choices, showcasing the potential new applications of XRDCT in conservation science, including the study of cultural materials and their deterioration processes.
4. **Opening new research perspectives**: In the fields of analytical chemistry and material characterization, opening new perspectives for non-destructive and non-invasive analysis of reactions within heterogeneous polycrystalline systems.