Effect of screw holes on the biomechanics of long tubular bone
Ming Yang,Bao-guo Jiang,Dian-ying Zhang,ZG Fu,JH Chen,HB Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2007.01.005
2007-01-01
Abstract:Aim: To investigate the effect of screw holes remained after removed the internal fixation of plate and nail on the biomechanics of long tubular bone. Methods: The experiment was carried out in the laboratory of Department of Orthopedics and Trauma, People's Hospital of Peking University from November 2004 to August 2005. Seventy-six pieces of Sanhuang cock tibia were selected and randomly divided into 7 groups: control group, 1.5 mm unicortical (unilateral cortex was drilled) one hole, bicortical 3 holes and bicortical 5 holes, and 2.5 mm unicortical one hole, bicortical 3 holes and bicortical 5 holes. The control group had normal complete cortex; the 1.5 mm and 2.5 mm unicortical one hole, bicortical 3 holes, and bicortical 5 holes served as corresponding number screw hole models. All the specimens of 7 groups were subjected to single three-points bending test. Results: 1 When there were bone structure destructions, the maximal bending loads of 1.5 mm unicortical one hole [(16.69±0.66)% of the average outer diameters of tubular bone (transverse diameter+vertical diameter)/2], and bicortical 3 holes did not differed significantly from that of the control group [(366.61±53.23), (364.23±51.26), (362.26±41.40) N, P=0.438, 0.273], but the maximal bending load of 1.5 mm bicortical 5 holes [(314.72±57.61)N] was decreased 13% compared with the control group (P=0.033). 2 The maximal bending loads of 2.5 mm unicortical one hole [(29.36± 2.07)% of the average outer diameters of tubular bone], bicortical 3 holes and bicortical 5 holes were [(315.55±51.09), (315.83±31.00), (280.81±49.18) N], which decreased 12%, 12% and 22% compared with the control group and there were significant differences (P=0.02, 0.015, 0.001). Conclusion: If the diameter of screw hole on the cortex of long tubular bone is within (16.69±0.66)% of bone cortical outer diameter, and there are only 3 bicortical holes or less, the bending load does not decrease; Once the diameter of screw hole is beyond (29.36±2.07)% of bone cortical outer diameter, the maximal bending load would be decreased apparently. The number of screw holes is not in proportion to the reduction extent of bending load; when there are few bicortical holes, the reduction extent is the same to unicortical one hole.