Abstract:Standard assessments and algorithms in Pediatrics are increasingly recognized as tools that have the potential to perpetuate racial and ethnic health inequities. The Apgar score is an assessment of an infant's physiologic condition after birth and response to initial resuscitation. 1 Components of the score include: heart rate, breathing, muscle tone, reflex response, and color, with each assigned a score of 0-2 at 1 and 5 min of life. The scoring system was developed in 1952 by anesthesiologist, Dr. Virginia Apgar, with the intention to provide a rapid evaluation of the need for resuscitation and increase survival of poorly scoring infants. 2 At present, the score is globally used in clinical practice and research. 3 Low scores may inform clinical decisions on the need for therapeutic intervention such as intensive care monitoring. Several score components are subjective, leading to interobserver variability. 1 The color assessment specifically assigns a score of 0 if blue or pale all over, 1 if blue in the extremities, and 2 if pink all over. Concerns have been raised in whether these descriptors appropriately reflect multiethnic variations in skin tone. 4,5 In the 1953 article proposing the score, Dr. Apgar herself states the color score "is by far the most unsatisfactory sign and caused the most discussion among the observers". 2 Recent literature has shown racial/ethnic score variations as Black infants often receive lower scores, notably in the appearance component, even when adjusted for known risk factors. 4,5 In this issue of Pediatric Research , the systematic review by Fair et al. contributes to existing evidence by exploring Apgar scores and cyanosis assessments among Black, Asian, and ethnic minority neonates. 3 Authors analyzed associations between subjective skin color examinations and objective measures of wellbeing. The largest studies in the review showed that, for the same low Apgar scores, Black infants had lower mortality rates than White infants. This is despite national data showing that Black infants have higher overall neonatal mortality. Black neonates were also more likely to receive a low Apgar score. Authors conclude that scoring differences according to ethnicity may provide the most likely explanation of better survival among Black infants with low Apgar scores, with further evaluation required. The review also found that visual detection of cyanosis was poor for all ethnicities, suggesting the need for objective assessments of newborn health. Included studies on pulse oximetry found that occult hypoxemia was more likely in Black neonates. These findings highlight the limitations of visual assessment of cyanosis in those with darker skin tones, as well as scoring inconsistencies in the Apgar appearance component.

Systematic review of Apgar scores & cyanosis in Black, Asian, and ethnic minority infants

Color outside the lines: rethinking Apgar scores for equity

A review of the current policies and guidance regarding Apgar scoring and the detection of jaundice and cyanosis concerning Black, Asian and ethnic minority neonates

Understanding stakeholder perspectives on Apgar score, cyanosis and identifying jaundice in ethnic minority neonates

Racial, ethnic, and socio-economic disparities in neonatal ICU admissions among neonates born with cyanotic CHD in the United States, 2009–2018

Racial/Ethnic Disparity in NICU Quality of Care Delivery

Validity of Apgar Score as an Indicator of Neonatal SARS-CoV-2 Infection: A Scoping Review

Utility of Skin Tone on Pulse Oximetry in Critically Ill Patients: A Prospective Cohort Study

Racial discrepancy in pulse oximeter accuracy in preterm infants

Caucasian and African American racial disparity in neonatal hospital mortality

Impacts of Skin Color and Hypoxemia on Noninvasive Assessment of Peripheral Blood Oxygen Saturation: A Scoping Review

Association between Apgar scores of 7 to 9 and neonatal mortality and morbidity: population based cohort study of term infants in Sweden

Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Neonatal Sepsis

Apgar Score Components at 5 Minutes: Risks and Prediction of Neonatal Mortality

Apgar score and neonatal mortality in China: an observational study from a national surveillance system

An Assessment of the Relationships Between Umbilical Cord Blood Gas Analysis, APGAR (Appearance, Pulse, Grimace, Activity, and Respiration) Scores, and Neonatal Outcomes

The contribution of low Apgar scores in identifying neonates with short-term morbidities in a large single center cohort

Interventions to mitigate pregnancy-related mortality and morbidity in Black birthing people: a systematic review

Low Apgar Score and Risk of Neonatal Mortality among Infants with Birth Defects

Immigrant and minority parents' experiences in a neonatal intensive care unit: A meta‐ethnography review

Differences in Morbidity and Mortality Rates in Black, White, and Hispanic Very Preterm Infants Among New York City Hospitals