Abstract:Background: Smart-home technologies, comprising environmental sensors, wearables and video are attracting interest in home healthcare delivery. Development of such technology is usually justified on the basis of the technology's potential to increase the autonomy of people living with long-term conditions. Studies of the ethics of smart-homes raise concerns about privacy, consent, social isolation and equity of access. Few studies have investigated the ethical perspectives of smart-home engineers themselves. By exploring the views of engineering researchers in a large smart-home project, we sought to contribute to dialogue between ethics and the engineering community. Methods: Either face-to-face or using Skype, we conducted in-depth qualitative interviews with 20 early- and mid-career smart-home researchers from a multi-centre smart-home project, who were asked to describe their own experience and to reflect more broadly about ethical considerations that relate to smart-home design. With participants' consent, interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed using a thematic approach. Results: Two overarching themes emerged: in 'Privacy', researchers indicated that they paid close attention to negative consequences of potential unauthorised information sharing in their current work. However, when discussing broader issues in smart-home design beyond the confines of their immediate project, researchers considered physical privacy to a lesser extent, even though physical privacy may manifest in emotive concerns about being watched or monitored. In 'Choice', researchers indicated they often saw provision of choice to end-users as a solution to ethical dilemmas. While researchers indicated that choices of end-users may need to be restricted for technological reasons, ethical standpoints that restrict choice were usually assumed and embedded in design. Conclusions: The tractability of informational privacy may explain the greater attention that is paid to it. However, concerns about physical privacy may reduce acceptability of smart-home technologies to future end-users. While attention to choice suggests links with privacy, this may misidentify the sources of privacy and risk unjustly burdening end-users with problems that they cannot resolve. Separating considerations of choice and privacy may result in more satisfactory treatment of both. Finally, through our engagement with researchers as participants this study demonstrates the relevance of (bio)ethics as a critical partner to smart-home engineering.

Motivation, Design, and Ubiquity: A Discussion of Research Ethics and Computer Science

"That's important, but...": How Computer Science Researchers Anticipate Unintended Consequences of Their Research Innovations

Don't "research fast and break things": On the ethics of Computational Social Science

Ethics in Computing Education: Challenges and Experience with Embedded Ethics

How do Computer Science Students Make Decisions in Ethical Situations? Implications for Teaching Computing Ethics based on a Grounded Theory Study

Ethical Design of Computers: From Semiconductors to IoT and Artificial Intelligence

Special Issue on Ethics in Computing

Smart homes, private homes? An empirical study of technology researchers' perceptions of ethical issues in developing smart-home health technologies

Privacy in computer ethics: Navigating the digital age

Ethical and Legal Challenges in Information System Development and Implementation

Ethics in Security Research: Visions, Reality, and Paths Forward

Software Engineering and Ethics: Navigating the Ethical Landscape in the Digital Age

Abstracted Power and Responsibility in Computer Science Ethics Education

The Case for Anticipating Undesirable Consequences of Computing Innovations Early, Often, and Across Computer Science

Responsible developments and networking research: a reflection beyond a paper ethical statement

Data and science engineering: The ethical dilemma of our time-exploring privacy breaches, algorithmic biases, and the need for transparency

Murder by design: Design thinking approach for pre-emptive cybernetic security design

Ethics in the Age of AI: Research of the Intersection of Technology, Morality, and Society

The Ethics of Machine Consciousness: Components, Detection, and Implications

"This Applies to the RealWorld": Student Perspectives on Integrating Ethics into a Computer Science Assignment

Ethical Frameworks and Computer Security Trolley Problems: Foundations for Conversations