Responsible developments and networking research: a reflection beyond a paper ethical statement

Daphne Tuncer,Marc Bruyere
2024-02-01
Abstract:Several recent initiatives have proposed new directions for research practices and their operations in the computer science community, from updated codes of conduct that clarify the use of AI-assisted tools to the inclusion of ethical statements and the organization of working groups on the environmental footprint of digitalization. In this position paper, we focus on the specific case of networking research. We reflect on the technical realization of the community and its incidence beyond techno-centric contributions. In particular, we structure the discussion around two frameworks that were recently developed in different contexts to describe the sense of engagement and responsibilities to which the practitioner of a computing-related area may be confronted.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the social, ethical and environmental impacts of networking research beyond the technical level, and to reflect on the responsibilities that researchers should bear in these aspects. Specifically, the author hopes to introduce a broader perspective in the field of networking research, so that the research can not only focus on technological innovation, but also consider its far - reaching impacts on society, the environment and human interaction. ### Main Content and Structure of the Paper 1. **Introduction**: - Reviewed the development of the networking research field since 2011 and its role in the global digital transformation. - Emphasized the impact of the current digital process on the global economy and society, as well as the challenges brought about, such as climate change, environmental crises, etc. - Pointed out that the scientific research community needs to rethink research practices, especially in terms of ethics and social responsibility. 2. **Current Situation of Networking Research**: - Introduced the definition of networking research and its wide range of application areas, including communication systems, Internet infrastructure, distributed systems, etc. - Proposed three methods to outline the diversity of networking research: professional organization classification, keyword analysis and directly listening to the opinions of researchers. - Demonstrated the topics and technical details of networking research by analyzing the web page content of academic research groups. 3. **Beyond the Technical Dimension**: - Explored the social and physical impacts of networking research in five aspects: time, space, interaction, automation and environment. - Emphasized how network technologies change human perception of time, spatial relationships, interaction patterns and the impact on the environment. - Analyzed the vision of automated networks and its impact on human operators, and pointed out that current research focuses too much on performance indicators and ignores the human factor. 4. **Sense of Responsibility and Sense of Participation**: - Drew on two frameworks to describe the sense of responsibility and sense of participation that practitioners in computing - related fields may face. - One is the framework of big questions about digital technology and AI ethics proposed by the French National Digital Ethics Commission. - The other is the four - level ethical participation model proposed by Chiodo and Bursill - Hall, from different levels of no sense of responsibility to active advocacy. ### Goals of the Paper - **Initiate Discussion**: Introduce the discussion of ethics and social responsibility in the computer networking research community and make it a core issue. - **Propose Action Recommendations**: Incorporate these issues into scientific debates through specific steps and measures, and promote multi - disciplinary cooperation to jointly address the challenges brought about by digitalization. ### Conclusion The paper emphasizes that networking research should not be limited to technological progress only, but also should pay attention to its far - reaching impacts on society, the environment and human interaction. By introducing the perspective of ethics and social responsibility, the future research direction can be better guided to ensure that technological development meets social needs and sustainable development goals.