From decision aiding to the massive use of algorithms: where does the responsibility stand?

Odile Bellenguez,Nadia Branuer,Alexis Tsoukiàs
2024-06-19
Abstract:In the very large debates on ethics of algorithms, this paper proposes an analysis on human responsibility. On one hand, algorithms are designed by some humans, who bear a part of responsibility in the results and unexpected impacts. Nevertheless, we show how the fact they cannot embrace the full situations of use and consequences lead to an unreachable limit. On the other hand, using technology is never free of responsibility, even if there also exist limits to characterise. Massive uses by unprofessional users introduce additional questions that modify the possibilities to be ethically responsible. The article is structured in such a way as to show how the limits have gradually evolved, leaving unthought of issues and a failure to share responsibility.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the issue of liability attribution in algorithm ethics. Specifically, it analyzes how human liability changes and the challenges it faces during the process in which algorithms develop from decision - making auxiliary tools to large - scale use. The paper points out that although algorithms are designed by humans, and designers bear certain liability for algorithm results and their unexpected impacts, designers cannot fully foresee all application scenarios and consequences of algorithms, which leads to an unreachable liability limit. Meanwhile, the use of technology is not without liability. Even with limitations, the widespread use by non - professional users has introduced new ethical liability issues. The article also discusses how the automation of various components in the decision - making process affects liability distribution as the degree of automation increases, and the impact of this standardized treatment on practical work and ethical decision - making. The structure of the paper is as follows: 1. **Introduction**: Introduce the importance of algorithm ethics and emphasize how technological means help humans maintain decision - making autonomy and a sense of responsibility. 2. **Decision - making Assistance**: Review the literature in the field of operations research and discuss the history and different aspects of ethical issues in decision - support systems. 3. **Impact of Automation**: Explore the impact of decision - making process automation on the liability of participants. 4. **Problems of Large - scale Use**: Discuss the problems brought about by the large - scale use of decision - support algorithms. 5. **Experimental Part**: Introduce a student experiment on designing a responsible route - planning service. 6. **Conclusion**: Summarize the full text and raise questions for further research. Through these discussions, the paper aims to reveal the complexity of liability distribution in algorithm ethics, especially how to balance the liabilities of designers, analysts and decision - makers during the process in which algorithms evolve from a single decision - support tool to a widely - used automated system.