Delegating Responsibilities to Intelligent Autonomous Systems: Challenges and Benefits

Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic,Gianfranco Basti,Tobias Holstein

2024-11-07

Abstract:As AI systems increasingly operate with autonomy and adaptability, the traditional boundaries of moral responsibility in techno-social systems are being challenged. This paper explores the evolving discourse on the delegation of responsibilities to intelligent autonomous agents and the ethical implications of such practices. Synthesizing recent developments in AI ethics, including concepts of distributed responsibility and ethical AI by design, the paper proposes a functionalist perspective as a framework. This perspective views moral responsibility not as an individual trait but as a role within a socio-technical system, distributed among human and artificial agents. As an example of 'AI ethical by design,' we present Basti and Vitiello's implementation. They suggest that AI can act as artificial moral agents by learning ethical guidelines and using Deontic Higher-Order Logic to assess decisions ethically. Motivated by the possible speed and scale beyond human supervision and ethical implications, the paper argues for 'AI ethical by design', while acknowledging the distributed, shared, and dynamic nature of responsibility. This functionalist approach offers a practical framework for navigating the complexities of AI ethics in a rapidly evolving technological landscape.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the challenges faced by traditional moral responsibility boundaries and their ethical implications in the context of the increasing autonomy and adaptability of intelligent autonomous systems (such as AI). Specifically, the paper explores the ethical issues when delegating responsibility to intelligent autonomous agents (such as AI systems), and proposes a functionalist perspective as a framework to understand and manage this distributed responsibility. The paper emphasizes the importance of embedding ethical principles into AI systems at the design stage, that is, "AI ethical design", to ensure that the decisions of these systems can conform to human values, while taking into account the distributed, shared and dynamic nature of responsibility. In addition, the paper also discusses how to design AI systems to have the ethical ability to evaluate their decisions, and how to achieve continuous learning and adaptation in sociotechnical systems to cope with the rapidly changing technological environment and social norms.