Abstract:The computing education research community now has at least 40 years of published research on teaching ethics in higher education. To examine the state of our field, we present a systematic literature review of papers in the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) computing education venues that describe teaching ethics in higher-education computing courses. Our review spans all papers published to SIGCSE, ICER, ITiCSE, CompEd, Koli Calling, and TOCE venues through 2022, with 100 papers fulfilling our inclusion criteria. Overall, we found a wide variety in content, teaching strategies, challenges, and recommendations. The majority of the papers did not articulate a conception of “ethics,” and those that did used many different conceptions, from broadly-applicable ethical theories, to social impact, to specific computing application areas (e.g., data privacy, hacking). Instructors used many different pedagogical strategies (e.g., discussions, lectures, assignments) and formats (e.g., standalone courses, incorporated within a technical course). Many papers identified measuring student knowledge as a particular challenge, and 59% of papers included mention of assessments or grading. Of the 69% of papers that evaluated their ethics instruction, most used student self-report surveys, course evaluations, and instructor reflections. While many papers included calls for more ethics content in computing, specific recommendations were rarely broadly applicable, preventing a synthesis of guidelines. To continue building on the last 40 years of research and move toward a set of best practices for teaching ethics in computing, our community should delineate our varied conceptions of ethics, examine which teaching strategies are best suited for each, and explore how to measure student learning.

Abstracted Power and Responsibility in Computer Science Ethics Education

How do Computer Science Students Make Decisions in Ethical Situations? Implications for Teaching Computing Ethics based on a Grounded Theory Study

Embedded EthiCS: Integrating Ethics Broadly Across Computer Science Education

Ethics in Computing Education: Challenges and Experience with Embedded Ethics

"This Applies to the RealWorld": Student Perspectives on Integrating Ethics into a Computer Science Assignment

Proposal for the Development of Social Responsibility and Professional Ethics in the Computer Engineering Curriculum

Case Study Based Pedagogical Intervention for Teaching Software Engineering Ethics

A Realist Review of Undergraduate Student Attitudes towards Ethical Interventions in Technical Computing Courses

Motivation, Design, and Ubiquity: A Discussion of Research Ethics and Computer Science

Socially Responsible Computing in an Introductory Course

Incorporating Ethics in Computing Courses: Perspectives from Educators

Abstraction Engineering

A New Model for Weaving Responsible Computing Into Courses Across the CS Curriculum

Using Distributed Cognition Theory to Analyze Collaborative Computer Science Learning

Public Computing Intellectuals in the Age of AI Crisis

Teaching UbiComp With an Integrated Ethics and Societal Implications Twist

Engaging Equity Pedagogies in Computer Science Learning Environments

The Power of Attention: Bridging Cognitive Load, Multimedia Learning, and AI

Navigating the Grey Area: Students' Ethical Dilemmas in Using AI Tools for Coding Assignments

Ethical Frameworks and Computer Security Trolley Problems: Foundations for Conversations

Teaching Ethics in Computing: A Systematic Literature Review of ACM Computer Science Education Publications