Abstract:We analyze a category of problems that is of interest in many physical situations, including those encountered in introductory physics classes: systems with two well-delineated parts that exchange energy, eventually reaching a shared equilibrium with a loss of mechanical or electrical energy. Such systems can be constrained by a constant of the system (e.g., mass, charge, momentum, or angular momentum) that uniquely determines the mechanical or electrical energy of the equilibrium state, regardless of the dissipation mechanism. A representative example would be a perfectly inelastic collision between two objects in one dimension, for which momentum conservation requires that some of the initial kinetic energy is dissipated by conversion to thermal or other forms as the two objects reach a common final velocity. We discuss how this feature manifests in a suite of four well-known and disparate problems that all share a common mathematical formalism. These examples, in which the energy dissipated during the process can be difficult to solve directly from dissipation rates, can be approached by students in a first-year physics class by considering conservation laws and can therefore be useful for teaching about energy transformations and conserved quantities. We then illustrate how to extend this method by applying it to a final example.

On Energy Perspective to Galileo's kinematic Paradox

Hamilton Equations, Commutator, and Energy Conservation

Classical Mechanics from Energy Conservation or: Why not Momentum?

Galilean relativity, special relativity and the work-kinetic energy theorem revisited

A Pamphlet against The Energy

Momentum work and the energetic foundations of physics. I. Newton’s laws of motion tailored to processes

Energy Conservation Equations of Motion

Resolving Absorbed Work and Generalized Inertia Forces From System Energy Equation—A Hamiltonian and Phase-Space Kinematics Approach

Conservation laws and energy transformations in a class of common physics problems

Finding the more fundamental law of classical mechanics

Inertia in 4D-mechanics

Is the Energy Balance Paradox Solved?

The energy equation for nonholonomic systems with nonlinear kinematic restrictions: a special category of constraints

Momentum work and the energetic foundations of physics. IV. The essence of heat, entropy, enthalpy, and Gibbs free energy

Energy Transformations in a Relativistic Engine

Paradoxos da Relatividade

Learning from Paradoxes

On Magnetic Forces and Work

Inconsistencies and errors in traditional approaches to energy in our introductory courses

The Paradigm of Projectile Motion and its Consequences for Special Relativity. Making Sense of Physics

Grounding Analytical Mechanics in Statics: A Didactic Emphasis on the Principle of Virtual Work