Finding the more fundamental law of classical mechanics

Vedat Tanriverdi

2024-07-21

Abstract:We have studied the relationship between the conservation of energy and Newton's second law or equations of motion. Differently from recent works, we show that equations of motion can be obtained only in some special cases and their results are distinct in general. This distinctiveness makes it possible to find the more fundamental law experimentally.

General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the relationship between the law of conservation of energy and Newton's second law (or the equation of motion) in classical mechanics and attempts to address the following core issues:

1. **Comparing the Fundamental Nature of Both**: The paper aims to determine, through theoretical analysis, which is more fundamental in the classical mechanics system: the law of conservation of energy or Newton's second law.

2. **Experimental Verification of Theoretical Differences**: The author points out that in certain cases, the equation of motion can be derived from the conservation of energy, but there are subtle differences between the two in multidimensional situations. The paper further suggests the possibility of an experimental design to verify the differences between these two methods of describing the behavior of physical systems, thereby determining which law is more fundamental.

Specifically, the author demonstrates, by studying single-degree-of-freedom systems and multi-degree-of-freedom systems (such as the double pendulum system), that the equations derived from the conservation of energy are not always consistent with those obtained directly from Lagrange's equations. This finding provides a theoretical basis for using experimental means to determine which principle is more fundamental. If the experimental results are consistent with the equations derived solely from the conservation of energy, it can be considered that the conservation of energy is more fundamental than Newton's second law; conversely, if the experimental results are consistent with the motion equations derived from Newton's second law, more experimental evidence is needed to determine whether the conservation of energy is a result of Newton's second law.