Astrophysical consequences of the OPERA superluminal neutrino

Luis Gonzalez-Mestres

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1109.6630

2011-09-29

General Physics

Abstract:A simple discussion of the recent OPERA result on the apparent critical speed of the muon neutrino is presented. We point out in particular some of the possible consistency problems of such an interpretation of the OPERA data with respect to well-established astrophysical observations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Phantom of the Opera: Superluminal Neutrinos

Bo-Qiang Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s0217732312300054

2012-01-01

Modern Physics Letters A

Abstract:This report presents a brief review on the experimental measurements of the muon neutrino velocities from the OPERA, Fermilab and MINOS experiments and that of the (anti)-electron neutrino velocities from the supernova SN1987A, and consequently on the theoretical attempts to attribute the data as signals for superluminality of neutrinos. Different scenarios on how to understand and treat the background fields in the effective field theory frameworks are pointed out. Challenges on interpreting the OPERA result as a signal of neutrino superluminality are briefly reviewed and discussed. It is also pointed out that a covariant picture of Lorentz violation may avoid the refutation on the OPERA experiment.
Superluminal neutrino speeds from SN 1987A and from OPERA experiment do agree very well

H. Genreith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1112.0353

2011-12-01

General Physics

Abstract:We give an explanation on the effect of superluminal neutrinos in the OPERA experiment and show that the SN 1987A data and the recent OPERA data do agree well by the use of common known physics. The data in addition can give a good number for the matter-antimatter asymmetry at big bang time.
Third road to the OPERA: a tunnel after all?

Giovanni Amelino-Camelia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1201.6496

2012-01-31

Abstract:The debate on OPERA focused on two extremes: either "OPERA is wrong" or our formulation of the laws of physics needs a major overhaul. I here argue that some effort should be directed toward manifestations of laws that are already known, but whose implications are poorly understood in OPERA-type contexts. My preferred example of this sort is that the OPERA result might be the first observation of a previously unnoticed effect, belonging to a family of effects which includes those responsible for the well-known peculiar properties of the "tunneling time". Tentative support for this specific hypothesis comes from the presence of evanescence and "postselection", and the observation that the fraction of neutrinos absorbed in rock on the way from CERN to LNGS is of a few parts in $10^5$, i.e. comparable to the fraction of the overall travel time by which OPERA neutrinos are found to reach LNGS earlier than expected. This leads me to stress that the OPERA result is still consistent with subluminality of a suitably "postselection-corrected" velocity. Adopting the popular (but here disfavored) interpretation of the OPERA result as a "signal velocity" one could obtain superluminal values of the postselection-corrected velocity in some technologically feasible OPERA-like setups, a prediction which I propose to test. I also propose a semi-heuristic formula for the "rock dwell time" and find that it gives a result in rough agreement with the OPERA travel-time measurements. This suggests that effects similar to the ones found for OPERA's muon neutrinos should also be found, but with tangibly different magnitude, for muon anti-neutrinos under similar experimental conditions. And I argue that, whether or not they end up being relevant for the OPERA anomaly, the effects here considered should be significant in the Planck-scale realm.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
OPERA neutrinos and superluminal helical motion

E. Canessa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.0245

2011-10-05

Abstract:We pinpoint how a subatomic particle with non-zero mass may attain, in principle, velocities faster-than-light by travelling in helical motion in the limit of very large momentum. This is an educated guess by virtue of the MINOS and OPERA experiments on eventual superluminal propagation of neutrinos.

General Physics
General relativity and OPERA Experiment

Christian Corda

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1201.4437

2012-11-09

Abstract:In his paper "A very simple solution to the OPERA neutrino velocity problem" the author J. Manuel Garcia-Islas claims to have very easily solved and explained within the general theory of relativity that OPERA's neutrinos are not traveling faster than the speed of light and the early time arrival is due to the presence of the Earth's gravitational field. In this letter we easily show that the argument by Garcia-Islas does not work. Although it looks that data suggesting that neutrinos can travel faster than light probably resulted from a faulty connection in a GPS timing system, it is important to clarify that, in any case, the general relativistic effect discussed by Garcia-Islas cannot explain the original OPERA's data.

General Physics
More than one ultimate speed and superluminal neutrinos

Jong-Phil Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1203.4052

2012-03-19

Abstract:It is suggested that recent superluminal neutrinos from the OPERA collaboration might indicate that there are other ultimate speeds than usual speed of light in our universe. The leptonic sector of the standard model (SM) is reformulated incorporating with new ultimate speeds. In minimal cases where there is another maximum speed $c'$ which equals to the speed of the OPERA neutrinos, new effects would appear at the level of ${\cal O}(10^{-5})$. Improved precisions for the electroweak observables would check the validity of this scenario.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
OPERA, SN1987a and energy dependence of superluminal neutrino velocity

N. D. Hari Dass

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.0351

2011-10-03

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

Abstract:This is a brief note discussing the energy dependence of superluminal neutrino velocities recently claimed by OPERA [1,2]. The analysis is based on the data provided there on this issue, as well as on consistency with neutrino data from SN1987a as recorded by the Kamioka detector [3]. It is seen that it is quite difficult to reconcile OPERA with SN1987a. The so called Coleman- Glashow dispersion relations do not do that well, if applied at all neutrino energies. The so called quantum gravity inspired dispersion relations perform far worse. Near OPERA energies both an energy-independent velocity, as well as a linear energy dependence with an offset that is comparable in value to the observed {\delta}v by OPERA at 28.1 GeV works very well. Our analysis shows that precision arrival time data from SN1987a still allow for superluminal behaviour for supernova neutrinos. A smooth interpolation is given that reconciles OPERA and SN1987a quite well. It suggests a fourth power energy dependence for {\delta}v of supernova neutrinos. This behaviour is insensitive to whether the velocities are energy-independent, or linearly dependent on energy, near OPERA scale of energies. Suggestions are made for experimental checks for these relations.
Using an Einstein's idea to explain OPERA faster than light neutrinos

Rafael Torrealba

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.0243

2012-11-27

Abstract:The OPERA experiment has reported neutrinos, from the CNGS beam, that arrived to Gran Sasso Laboratory 60ns earlier that expected for light, within a statistical error margin of §6:9 and a systemic error of §7:4. Therefore, these neutrinos are faster than known velocity of the light in vacuum. These puzzling result could be explained by stimulated emission of neutrinos in the decay tunnel, in close analogy with the amplification of a LASER pulse.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment
Are OPERA neutrinos faster than light because of non-inertial reference frames?

Claudio Germana

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201118745

2012-01-20

Abstract:Recent results from the OPERA experiment reported a neutrino beam traveling faster than light. The experiment measured the neutrino time of flight (TOF) over a baseline from the CERN to the Gran Sasso site. The neutrino beam arrives 60 ns earlier than a light ray would do. Because the result has an enormous impact on science, it might be worth double-checking the time definitions with respect to the non-inertial system in which the neutrino travel time was measured. Potential problems in the OPERA data analysis connected with the definition of the reference frame and time synchronization are emphasized. We aim to investigate the synchronization of non-inertial clocks on Earth by relating this time to the proper time of an inertial observer at Solar System Barycenter(SSB). The Tempo2 software was used to time-stamp events observed on the geoid with respect to the SSB inertial observer time. Neutrino results from OPERA might carry the fingerprint of non-inertial effects. The CERN-Gran Sasso clock synchronization is accomplished by applying corrections that depend on special and general relativistic time dilation effects at the clocks, depending on the position of the clocks in the solar system gravitational well. As a consequence, TOF distributions are centered on values shorter by tens of ns than expected, integrating over a period from April to December, longer if otherwise. It is worth remarking that the OPERA runs have always been carried out from April/May to November. If the analysis by Tempo2 holds for the OPERA experiment, the excellent measurement by the OPERA collaboration will turn into a proof of the General Relativity theory in a weak field approximation. The analysis presented here is falsifiable because it predicts that performing the experiment from January to March/April, the neutrino beam will be detected to arrive 50 ns later than light.

General Physics
Narrowing of the neutrino light curve in the OPERA experiment

Maurice H. P. M. van Putten,Maurice H.P.M. van Putten

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.4781

2011-10-21

High Energy Physics - Experiment

Abstract:In the OPERA experiment, the time of arrival of the neutrino light curve at LNGS is defined by a best-fit to the generating proton PDF at CERN. By a two parameter matched filtering procedure, we determine that the OPERA neutrino light curve is narrower by about 0.4-0.5% relative to the proton PDF. The results indicate as yet undetermined physics in the creation of neutrinos in CERN and a reduced significance of the OPERA detection to less than 4 $\sigma.$
Non-standard interactions using the OPERA experiment

Mattias Blennow,Davide Meloni,Tommy Ohlsson,Francesco Terranova,Mattias Westerberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-008-0683-6

2008-04-17

Abstract:We investigate the implications of non-standard interactions on neutrino oscillations in the OPERA experiment. In particular, we study the non-standard interaction parameter $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$. We show that the OPERA experiment has a unique opportunity to reduce the allowed region for this parameter compared with other experiments such as the MINOS experiment, mostly due to the higher neutrino energies in the CNGS beam compared to the NuMI beam. We find that OPERA is mainly sensitive to a combination of standard and non-standard parameters and that a resulting anti-resonance effect could suppress the expected number of events. Furthermore, we show that running OPERA for five years each with neutrinos and anti-neutrinos would help in resolving the degeneracy between the standard parameters and $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$. This scenario is significantly better than the scenario with a simple doubling of the statistics by running with neutrinos for ten years.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Superluminal Neutrinos in the Minimal Standard Model Extension

Nan Qin,Bo-Qiang Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217751X12500455

2012-03-27

Abstract:Most recently, the measurement of the neutrino velocity with the OPERA detector in the CNGS beam shows unexpected indication, that the muon neutrino velocity, $v_{\nu}$, exceeds the velocity of light in the vacuum, $c$, which is obviously in contradiction with the most basic hypothesis of modern physics. Within the framework of minimal Standard Model Extension, we discuss the modified dispersion relation and consequently the velocity-energy relation of muon neutrinos. The simplified models are fit to the OPERA data, Fermilab experiment and MINO data. We find that minimal Standard Extension can describe these long baseline superluminal neutrinos to a good accuracy. For the well-known tension between the OPERA measurement and the Supernova 1987A neutrino observation, we discussed two ways out of the contradiction.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Neutrino Velocity and Neutrino Oscillations

H. Minakata,A. Yu. Smirnov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.85.113006

2012-07-30

Abstract:We study distances of propagation and the group velocities of the muon neutrinos in the presence of mixing and oscillations assuming that Lorentz invariance holds. Oscillations lead to distortion of the $\nu_\mu$ wave packet which, in turn, changes the group velocity and the distance $\nu_\mu$ travels. We find that the change of the distance, $d_{osc}$, is proportional to the length of the wave packet, $\sigma_x$, and the oscillation phase, $\phi_p$, acquired by neutrinos in the $\pi-$ and $K-$ meson decay tunnel where neutrino wave packet is formed: $d_{osc} \propto \sigma \phi_p$. Although the distance $d_{osc}$ may effectively correspond to the superluminal motion, the effect is too tiny ($\sim 10^{- 5}$ cm) to be reconciled with the OPERA result. We analyze various possibilities to increase $d_{osc}$ and discuss experimental setups in which $d_{osc}$ (corresponding to the superluminal motion) can reach an observable value $\sim 1$ m.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
On the rationality of the OPERA experiment as a signal of Lorentz violation

Zhou Lingli,Bo-Qiang Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1111.1574

2011-11-07

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

Abstract:We show that the superluminal muon neutrinos in the recent OPERA experiment can exist theoretically. The refutation of the OPERA experiment from some theoretical arguments is not universally valid, but resulting from some implicit assumptions. Our argument can accommodate both the OPERA experiment for superluminal neutrinos and the ICARUS experiment of no evidence for the analogues Cherenkov radiation of muon neutrinos from CERN to the LNGS.
A short comment on OPERA neutrino velocity measuerement

Pierluigi Frabetti,Leonid Prokopievich Cernenko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1111.3116

2011-11-14

Abstract:In this report a potential problem in the data analysis of the OPERA experiment is discussed: the main issue is that the quantity "\partialt" used in the maximum likelihood procedure is not a "true" parameter of the parent-distribution (called PDF in the apaper) but a shift in the x-axis (time scale). This means that the quantity "\partialt" has to be considered only as systematic effect these error in not simply deducible from a gaussian distribution as stated.

High Energy Physics - Experiment
Is OPERA Neutrino Superluminal Propagation similar to Gain-Assisted Superluminal Light Propagation

Vladan Pankovic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1109.6121

2011-10-03

Abstract:In this work we consider a possible conceptual similarity between recent, amazing OPERA experiment of the superluminal propagation of neutrino and experiment of the gain-assisted superluminal light propagation realized about ten years ago. Last experiment refers on the propagation of the light, precisely laser pulse through a medium, precisely caesium atomic gas, with characteristic anomalous dispersion and corresponding negative group-velocity index with very large amplitude between two closely spaced gain lines (that is in some way similar to quantum theory of the ferromagnetism). It implies superluminal propagation of the light through this medium. Nevertheless all this, at it has been pointed out by authors, "is not at odds with causality or special relativity", since it simply represents "a direct consequence of the classical interference between ... different frequency components". We suggest that OPERA experiment can be in some way conceptually similar to the gain-assisted superluminal light propagation experiment. For this reason we suppose too that OPERA experiment can be simply explained in full agreement with causality and special relativity if there is some medium, precisely a scalar field (e.g. dark matter field, Higgs field or similar) through which neutrino propagates. We prove that, according to OPERA experiment data, supposed medium must be non-dispersive while its refractive index must be positive, smaller but relatively close to 1 (that is in some way similar to quantum theory of the diamagnetism). If it is true OPERA experiment results do not mean that special theory of relativity is broken, but they mean detection of suggested medium, i.e. a scalar field (e.g. dark matter field, Higgs field or similar).

General Physics
SUPERLUMINAL NEUTRINOS FROM SPECIAL RELATIVITY WITH DE SITTER SPACETIME SYMMETRY

Mu-Lin Yan,Neng-Chao Xiao,Wei Huang,Sen Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s0217732312500769

2012-01-01

Modern Physics Letters A

Abstract:We explore the recent OPERA experiment of superluminal neutrinos in the framework of special relativity with de Sitter spacetime symmetry (dS-SR). According to Einstein, a photon is treated as a massless particle in the framework of special relativity. In special relativity (SR) we have the universal parameter c, the photon velocity c photon and the phase velocity of a light wave in vacuum c wave = λν. Due to the null experiments of Michelson–Morley we have c = c wave . The parameter c photon is determined by the Noether charges corresponding to the spacetime symmetries of SR. In Einstein's special relativity (E-SR) we have c = c photon . In dS-SR, i.e. the special relativity with SO(4, 1) de Sitter spacetime symmetry, we have c photon > c. In this paper, the OPERA datum are examined in the framework of dS-SR. We show that OPERA anomaly is in agreement with the prediction of dS-SR with R≃1.95×1012 l.y. Based on the p-E relation of dS-SR, we also prove that the Cohen and Glashow's argument of possible superluminal neutrino's Cherenkov-like radiation is forbidden. We conclude that OPERA and ICARUS results are consistent and they are explained in the dS-SR framework.
Study of neutrino interactions with the electronic detectors of the OPERA experiment

OPERA Collaboration

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/13/5/053051

2011-02-09

Abstract:The OPERA experiment is based on a hybrid technology combining electronic detectors and nuclear emulsions. OPERA collected muon-neutrino interactions during the 2008 and 2009 physics runs of the CNGS neutrino beam, produced at CERN with an energy range of about 5-35 GeV. A total of $5.3 \times 10^{19}$ protons on target equivalent luminosity has been analysed with the OPERA electronic detectors: scintillator strips target trackers and magnetic muon spectrometers equipped with resistive plate gas chambers and drift tubes, allowing a detailed reconstruction of muon-neutrino interactions. Charged Current (CC) and Neutral Current (NC) interactions are identified, using the measurements in the electronic detectors, and the NC/CC ratio is computed. The momentum distribution and the charge of the muon tracks produced in CC interactions are analysed. Calorimetric measurements of the visible energy are performed for both the CC and NC samples. For CC events the Bjorken-$y$ distribution and the hadronic shower profile are computed. The results are compared to a detailed Monte Carlo simulation of the electronic detectors' response.

High Energy Physics - Experiment
Can OPERA help in constraining neutrino non-standard interactions?

A. Esteban-Pretel,J.W.F. Valle,P. Huber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2008.07.092

IF: 4.95

2008-10-01

Physics Letters B

Abstract:We study how much the unique ability of the OPERA experiment to directly detect ντ can help in probing new, non-standard contact interactions of the third family of neutrinos. We perform a combined analysis of future, high-statistics MINOS and OPERA data. For the case of non-standard interactions in νμ to νe transitions we also include the impact of possible Double Chooz data. In all cases we find that the ντ sample of OPERA is too small to be statistically significant, even if one doubles the nominal exposure of OPERA to 9×1019 pot. OPERA's real benefit for this measurement lies in its very high neutrino energy and hence very different L/E compared to MINOS.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields, nuclear
A note on superluminal neutrinos and deformed special relativity

Yi Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1111.3716

2011-11-16

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

Abstract:In this short note we remark that the OPERA measurement could be reconciled with information from SN1987a in the context of deformed special relativity without the loss of energy through Cherenkov-like process reported by Cohen and Glashow.

Astrophysical consequences of the OPERA superluminal neutrino

The Phantom of the Opera: Superluminal Neutrinos

Superluminal neutrino speeds from SN 1987A and from OPERA experiment do agree very well

Third road to the OPERA: a tunnel after all?

OPERA neutrinos and superluminal helical motion

General relativity and OPERA Experiment

More than one ultimate speed and superluminal neutrinos

OPERA, SN1987a and energy dependence of superluminal neutrino velocity

Using an Einstein's idea to explain OPERA faster than light neutrinos

Are OPERA neutrinos faster than light because of non-inertial reference frames?

Narrowing of the neutrino light curve in the OPERA experiment

Non-standard interactions using the OPERA experiment

Superluminal Neutrinos in the Minimal Standard Model Extension

Neutrino Velocity and Neutrino Oscillations

On the rationality of the OPERA experiment as a signal of Lorentz violation

A short comment on OPERA neutrino velocity measuerement

Is OPERA Neutrino Superluminal Propagation similar to Gain-Assisted Superluminal Light Propagation

SUPERLUMINAL NEUTRINOS FROM SPECIAL RELATIVITY WITH DE SITTER SPACETIME SYMMETRY

Study of neutrino interactions with the electronic detectors of the OPERA experiment

Can OPERA help in constraining neutrino non-standard interactions?

A note on superluminal neutrinos and deformed special relativity