Abstract:Remote sensing data capture ecologically important information that can be used to characterize, model and predict bird habitat. This study implements fusion techniques using Random Forests (RF) with spectral Landsat data and structural airborne laser scanning (ALS) data to scale habitat attributes through time and to characterize habitat for four bird species in dynamic young forest environments in the United Kingdom. We use multi-temporal (2000, 2005, 2012/13, 2015) multi-sensor (Landsat and ALS) data to (i) predict structural attributes via pixel-level fusion at 30 metre spatial resolution, (ii) model bird habitat via object-level fusion and compare with models based on ALS, Landsat and predicted structural attributes, and (iii) predict bird habitat through time (i.e., predict 2015 habitat based on 2000-2012 data). First, we found that models predicting mean height from spectral information had the highest accuracy, whilst maximum height, standard deviation of heights, foliage height diversity, canopy cover and canopy relief ratio had good accuracy, and entropy had low accuracy. The green band and the normalized burn ratio (NBR) were consistently important for prediction, with the red and shortwave infrared (SWIR) 1 bands also important. For all structural variables, high values were underpredicted and low values were overpredicted. Second, for Blue Tit (Cyanistes caeruleus) and Chaffinch (Fringilla coelebs), the most accurate model employed Landsat data, while object-level fusion performed best for Chiffchaff (Phylloscopus collybita) and Willow Warbler (Phylloscopus trochilus). ALS mean, maximum and standard deviation of heights and Landsat tasseled cap transformations (TCT) (i.e., wetness, greenness and brightness) were ranked as important to all species across various models. Third, we used our models to predict presence in 2015 and implemented a spatial intersection approach to assess the predictive accuracy for each species. Blue Tit and Willow Warbler presences were well predicted with the Landsat, ALS, and objectlevel fusion models. Chaffinch and Chiffchaff presences were best predicted with the ALS model. Predictions based on pixel-level predicted structure surfaces had low accuracy but were acceptable for Chaffinch and Willow Warbler. This study is significant as it provides guidance for Landsat and ALS data application and fusion in habitat modelling. Our results highlight the need to use appropriate remote sensing data for each study species based on their ecology. Object-level data fusion improved habitat characterization for all species relative to ALS, but not to Landsat for Blue Tit and Chaffinch. Pixel-level fusion for predicting structural attributes in years where ALS data are note available is increasingly being used in modelling but may not adequately represent within-patch wildlife habitat. Finally, incorporating predicted surfaces generated through pixel-level fusion in our habitat models yielded low accuracy.

Habitat Suitability in the Eyes of the Beholder: Using Random Forest Models to Predict Land Cover Type and Scale of Selection Through Avian Functional Traits

Predicting woodland bird species habitat with multi-temporal and multisensor remote sensing data

Step selection techniques uncover the environmental predictors of space use patterns in flocks of Amazonian birds

Predictive multi‐scale occupancy models at range‐wide extents: Effects of habitat and human disturbance on distributions of wetland birds

Choices to landscapes: Mechanisms of animal movement scale to landscape patterns

Estimating encounter-habitat relationships with scale-integrated resource selection functions

Evaluating the predictors of habitat use and successful reproduction in a model bird species using a large‐scale automated acoustic array

Deciphering ecology from statistical artefacts: Competing influence of sample size, prevalence and habitat specialization on species distribution models and how small evaluation datasets can inflate metrics of performance

Relationship between bird abundances and landscape characteristics: the influence of scale

Statistical Inference on Tree Swallow Migrations with Random Forests

Effects of grain size and niche breadth on species distribution modeling

Assessing the predictive value of morphological traits on primary lifestyle of birds through the extreme gradient boosting algorithm

Functional Traits and Environment Jointly Determine the Spatial Scaling of Population Stability in North American Birds

The influence of sampling scheme and interpolation method on the power to detect spatial effects of forest birds in Ontario (Canada)

Multi-scale habitat selection modeling: a review and outlook

Evaluating trade-offs in spatial versus temporal replication when estimating avian community composition and predicting species distributions

A dynamic multi‐scale occupancy model to estimate temporal dynamics and hierarchical habitat use for nomadic species

Taxonomic and functional components of avian metacommunity structure along an urban gradient.

Scale mismatches between predictor and response variables in species distribution modelling: A review of practices for appropriate grain selection

Adding structure to land cover - using fractional cover to study animal habitat use

Machine and deep learning approaches to understand and predict habitat suitability for seabird breeding